Code peer review - Githubissues

INFO-523-Exercises / project-final-The-Algo-Rhythms

The Algo-Rhythms team GitHub repository for Project Final from INFO 523 @ UArizona

https://info-523-exercises.github.io/project-final-The-Algo-Rhythms/

0 stars 2 forks source link

Code peer review #4

Closed Kevin-diesel-1194 closed 11 months ago

Kevin-diesel-1194 commented 11 months ago

The following is the peer review of the project code by Minecrafters. The team members that participated in this review are

Hari Dave - @haridave0718
Sarthak Miglani - @sarthakMiglani726
Partha Koundinya P - @partha-pkp
Vinu Kevin Diesel - @Kevin-diesel-1194
Syed Aslam Sheik Dawood - @Syedaslamsheikdawood

1. Purpose of Code

[x] Clearly defined and understood
[ ] Ambiguous or unclear

2. Code Quality

[ ] Code is clean, readable, and well-organized
[x] Adequate comments explaining complex or tricky code sections
[x] Variables, methods, and classes have meaningful names
[x] Consistent code style (indentation, naming conventions, etc.)

3. Documentation

[x] Code documentation (e.g., comments) is sufficient
[ ] Readme or other documentation updated if necessary

4. Best Practices

[x] No hardcoded values; constants used appropriately
[x] Security and privacy concerns addressed (e.g., no sensitive data exposed)
[x] Code avoids repetition and promotes reusability

5. Additional Comments

The code could be more organised, there are few empty cells in the code, and you can also add some more commments / descriptions to the code.

6. Recommendation

[ ] Approved - ready to be merged
[x] Approved with minor issues - can be addressed later
[ ] Requires changes - provide feedback and request another review

visalakshi2001 commented 11 months ago

Hello Team Minecrafters,

Thank you for the feedback. We have made the changes requires for complete approval

We will close this issue here