Possible workflow for viewing GML files with QGIS

[heidivanparys]

Prerequisites

QGIS is installed (includes OSGeo4W).

Workflow

1. Open the OSGeo4W Shell application.
2. Go to the folder where the GML file is located by using the cd command: cd C:\path\to\folder
3. Run the ogrinfo command: ogrinfo -al -oo GML_ATTRIBUTES_TO_OGR_FIELDS=YES gml_file_name.gml
4. A file gml_file_name.gfs is created. Edit it if desired.
5. Add the GML file to QGIS via the Add Vector Layer menu option.

Notes

.gfs files

Example:

<PropertyDefn>
    <!-- display name in QGIS -->
      <Name>endDesignationPeriod_indeterminate</Name>
    <!-- use | to access the value of a nested XML element -->
    <!-- use @ to access the value of an attribute -->
      <ElementPath>designationPeriod|TimePeriod|endPosition@indeterminatePosition</ElementPath>
    <!-- a Condition element may be added here, see documentation. -->
      <Type>String</Type>
      <Width>10</Width>
 </PropertyDefn>

Note: When editing the GML file again, the corresponding .gfs file must be resaved so it has a later timestamp than the GML file, else it will not be taken into account.

It is possible to specify the location of the .gfs file to use via a registry for GML application schemas, but you need administrator rights on your computer to edit gml_registry.xml (it is possible to point to a custom registry file, but QGIS does not support yet setting options for OGR, see below).

<gml_registry>
    <namespace prefix="am" uri="http://inspire.ec.europa.eu/schemas/am/4.0" useGlobalSRSName="true">
        <featureType elementName="ManagementRestrictionOrRegulationZone"
                 gfsSchemaLocation="am_config.gfs"/>
    </namespace>
</gml_registry>

ogrinfo

The ogrinfo command is documented on https://www.gdal.org/ogrinfo.html ogrinfo will recognize the file as a GML file and will therefore use the GML driver to open it, documented on https://www.gdal.org/drv_gml.html A "configuration option", see also https://trac.osgeo.org/gdal/wiki/ConfigOptions, can be set by using the following syntax (thus without equal sign): ogrinfo --config CONFIG_OPTION_NAME CONFIG_OPTION_VALUE

A "open option", also called "dataset open option", which is format specific, is set by using the following syntax (thus with equal sign): ogrinfo --oo OPEN_OPTION_NAME=OPEN_OPTION_VALUE

Certain functionalities in OGR are available both as a configuration option and as an open option, sometimes with a different name for the option, so double-check the documentation.

QGIS does not yet support setting these options via the UI (see https://issues.qgis.org/issues/20825), therefore ogrinfo must be run with the OSGeo4W Shell application, and the layer added with QGIS afterwards.

When open option GML_ATTRIBUTES_TO_OGR_FIELDS is set YES, attributes of GML elements are also taken into account (e.g. xlink:href). Note that this currently does not work for the nilReason attribute: https://github.com/OSGeo/gdal/issues/1154

[heidivanparys]

I added this issue because I only recently became aware of the possibility of this way of viewing GML files (as opposed to seeing only few attributes, or having to use the GML application schema toolbox plugin).

Ideas for tests for GML:

• viewing whether a property is nil (works only partially in QGIS: https://issues.qgis.org/issues/20824)
• viewing of nilReason attribute
• viewing of XML attributes in general

[PeterParslow]

These are three of the ideas that we (OS) came up with (in 2015) as 'things we would like to see' in desktop GIS clients viewing GML, after the OGC UK Interoperability Plugfest. See https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/about/governance/policies/gml-design.html and https://portal.opengeospatial.org/files/?artifact_id=61057

[sMorrone]

In QGIS 2.18 it is possible to view whether a property is nil and to display the nilReason attribute using the Complex GML Info plugin (not working for QGIS version 3)

[alexanderkotsev]

We opened an issue in the QGIS issue tracker proposing a feature for including the GML_ATTRIBUTES_TO_OGR_FIELDS=YES as default behaviour for GML loading.

[sgrellet]

I don't see the other ogr/gdal driver for GML ('https://gdal.org/drivers/vector/gmlas.html#vector-gmlas') mentionned. That's surprising as there was an important EU investment (EEA, BRGM, others) both on the driver and the capacity for QGIS plugins to use it (see https://plugins.qgis.org/plugins/gml_application_schema_toolbox/). Have you considered it ?

[alexanderkotsev]

The QGIS plugin + associated OGR/GDAL driver are considered. Please take a look at the results from the tests with data discovered through the INSPIRE Geoportal. You would notice that for many of the tests in the case of QGIS 3.x the functionality is considered as supported because of the QGIS plugin + ogr/gdal driver. Question is now how to ensure sustainability + continuity.

[sgrellet]

My bad. Indeed it's written 'Notes: need to use the 'GML Application Schema Toolbox' plugin' when clicking on some '3.4.4-Madeira' cells. Thanks Alex I'm reasured then :)

[heidivanparys]

I noticed that it actually is possible to have a setting in QGIS that makes the GML driver read XML attributes by default: GML_ATTRIBUTES_TO_OGR_FIELDS is both an open option as well as a configuration option. Configuration options can be set as environment variables, and environment variables can be set in QGIS: https://docs.qgis.org/testing/en/docs/user_manual/introduction/qgis_configuration.html#system-settings

This means that the workflow becomes as simple as this once the above configuration is applied:

1. Add the GML file to QGIS via the Add Vector Layer menu option.

[alexanderkotsev]

Thanks @heidivanparys. Interesting way forward which would likely require a minimal modification.

@timlinux do you think it is feasible from a QGIS point of view to overwrite the default behavior of QGIS for the GML_ATTRIBUTES through the System settings instead of hard-coding the GML_ATTRIBUTES_TO_OGR_FIELDS=YES in order to change the default behavior of QGIS with INSPIRE GML?

This means that the workflow becomes as simple as this once the above configuration is applied:

1. Add the GML file to QGIS via the Add Vector Layer menu option.

[heidivanparys]

QGIS does not yet support setting these options via the UI (see https://issues.qgis.org/issues/20825)

Setting that option via the UI of QGIS has been fixed, see https://github.com/qgis/QGIS/issues/28644#issuecomment-764687199 so GML_ATTRIBUTES_TO_OGR_FIELDS can be set on a dataset per dataset basis from within QGIS.