search

INSPIRE-MIF / helpdesk-registry

Community for the discussion of change proposals by the submitting organisations for the central INSPIRE registers and register federation and their resolution by the control body.
3 stars 0 forks source link

Add some new items in the Protocol Value register #17

Closed AntoRot closed 1 week ago

AntoRot commented 3 years ago

URI: http://inspire.ec.europa.eu/metadata-codelist/ProtocolValue

Motivation: We propose to add some items in the Protocol Value register because we need some missing codes to represent two types of resources, i.e.:

Proposed change: new proposed items:

Change type: addition

hernlor commented 3 years ago

Dear @AntoRot ,

Thank you for your request.

The scrutiny period begins now, and it is open to comments from the Control Body during the next two weeks.

Kind regards,

INSPIRE Registry team.

AntoRot commented 3 years ago

Thank you very much, @hernlor!

Please note that this addition will also imply a revision of the definition of the register.

Kind regards, Antonio

hernlor commented 3 years ago

Dear @AntoRot thank you for the patience.

We have discussed internally your proposal.

The addition of new values would imply a change in the definition and reasoning behind the code list as you rightly pointed out.

Because of the latter, the control body prefers not to approve the change at the moment and invites you to discuss their addition in the frame of "Action 2.3 "Simplification of INSPIRE implementation"[1] of the INSPIRE MIWP 2021-2024[2].

Alternatively, you can create an extension of the code lists to support your use case and share it through the Registry of registers applications.

[1] https://github.com/INSPIRE-MIF/gp-data-service-linking-simplification [2] https://webgate.ec.europa.eu/fpfis/wikis/display/InspireMIG/INSPIRE+work+programme+2021-24

Kind regards on behalf of the INSPIRE Registry control body.

AntoRot commented 3 years ago

Dear @hernlor,

Thank you for the attention of the INSPIRE Registry control body to the change proposal.

Our initial intention indeed was to publish the two items in the Italian registry (included in the INSPIRE register federation) as national extensions to the Protocol Value register, but we thought to first propose this change to the INSPIRE registry as it could be of interest for other Member States.

Now we'll proceed as you suggested, by both publishing the national extensions and discussing the proposal under the new action 2.3.

Anyway, I think that register should include all the possible reference codes to be used as protocol values and not be limited only to the scope defined under the simplification action.

Best regards, Antonio

hernlor commented 3 years ago

Thank you @AntoRot,

feel free to reopen this issue or link to this one after discussing the options under Action 2.3 "Simplification of INSPIRE implementation" of the INSPIRE MIWP 2021-2024.

Kind regards,

INSPIRE Registry team

jescriu commented 1 year ago

Dear @AntoRot, Taking into account the final progress on the Data-service linking simplification good practice proposal, under Action 2.3.2 Simplification of INSPIRE implementation, I proceed to reopen again this issue for further consideration by the Control Body. Jordi

AntoRot commented 9 months ago

In the light of the provisions laid down by the Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/138 (High-value datasets) and specifically the arrangement about the availability of datasets as bulk download, I think that this proposal should be reconsidered.

The new proposed item WWW:DOWNLOAD indeed could be used to denote the mandatory bulk download for spatial datasets falling under the above mentioned Regulation.

arantzaetxebarria commented 3 months ago

In the MIWP Action 2.3.1 MIG-T Sub-group Meeting on 06/05/2024, it was agreed to bring this proposal for endorsement in the 78 MIG-T Meeting.

arantzaetxebarria commented 3 months ago

The INSPIRE MIG-T approved the change proposal during the 78 MIG-T Meeting

arantzaetxebarria commented 1 week ago

We want to inform you that the proposal has been successfully published.

https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/metadata-codelist/ProtocolValue https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/metadata-codelist/ProtocolValue/www-download

Regards