search

INSPIRE-MIF / helpdesk-validator

Community discussion forum for INSPIRE validation issues
41 stars 22 forks source link

validate xml documents error #1100

Open trodin opened 1 month ago

trodin commented 1 month ago

Hello,

We have validation error in validating dataset for Population distribution: Conformance class: INSPIRE GML application schemas, General requirments Schema validation, validate XML documents saying:

XML document '2021_demography - housholds on municipality level_surface.gml': http://inspire.ec.europa.eu/schemas/pd/4.0/PopulationDistributionDemography.xsd, 2:35: s4s-elt-character: Non-whitespace characters are not allowed in schema elements other than 'xs:appinfo' and 'xs:documentation'. Saw '301 Moved Permanently'.

When I open schema: https://[inspire.ec.europa.eu/schemas/pd/4.0/PopulationDistributionDemography.xsd](https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/schemas/pd/4.0/PopulationDistributionDemography.xsd) in the root of the document we have xmlns:sc="http://www.interactive-instruments.de/ShapeChange/AppInfo"

But this link is not working: https://www.interactive-instruments.de/de/ShapeChange/AppInfo

Is that the cause of the validation error? schema validation error

Thank you Tanja

fabiovinci commented 1 month ago

Dear @trodin,

this should not be the cause of the validation error since the PopulationDistributionDemography.xsd is valid.

Could you please send us your GML file so that we can take a look?

trodin commented 1 month ago

File size too big: 25 MB are allowed, 29 MB were attempted to upload.

can I send it to some mail?

Thanks, Tanja

fabiovinci commented 1 month ago

You could generate a sample dataset, by reducing the number of feature members, or send the whole dataset by email (you can find it on my user page).

trodin commented 1 month ago

2021_demography by gender and agepopulation on county level_TR1novo.zip

I found this one smaller.

fabiovinci commented 1 month ago

Dear @trodin,

I validated your dataset, selecting both application schemas PD and SU, and I didn't detect the error you reported. See related report: https://inspire.ec.europa.eu/validator/test-run/details.html?id=EIDac19c162-e1a9-470b-91ec-f31447bcfe4c

In addition, test name is now different:

image

Which version of the validator did you use?

trodin commented 1 month ago

Ok, thank you.

I use some internal ETF validator on our infrastructure, not the online version since my data is too big for on line version.

Thank you for validating.

Regards, Tanja

trodin commented 1 month ago

Is there any other error, we had one more error related to geometry: image do you have that?

Thanks, Tanja

fabiovinci commented 1 month ago

Dear @trodin,

I confirm that the error mentioned was also present.

Fina attached the report: Test run on 13_45 - 23.07.2024 with test suite Annex III - Statistical units (SU) - IOS 1100.html.zip

trodin commented 1 month ago

Ok, now I see. But why The feature geometry is not a valid GML geometry?

And the first error is alos present in your validation report. It is in Conformance class: GML aplication schemas, Statistical Units and PD it is in test: Validation against INSPIRE official schema, su-gml.b1: validate XML documents against official schema:

How to correct that? image

fabiovinci commented 1 month ago

Regarding the geometry error "The feature geometry is not a valid GML geometry. Error detected: Invalid polygon. Outer ring of polygon is clockwise within element Surface,", you should fix it in the source dataset or during the generation of the gml file.

The errors in the test "Validation against INSPIRE official schema" should be due to the presence of two application schemas.

On the contrary, the test "Validation against declared schema" is passed.

image

We will further investigate if it's possible to avoid errors related to the presence of feature types from different application schemas.