search

INSPIRE-MIF / helpdesk-validator

Community discussion forum for INSPIRE validation issues
42 stars 23 forks source link

Wrong polygon orientation reported for CRS EPSG:3045/EPSG:4258 #950

Closed ulbrichtd closed 1 year ago

ulbrichtd commented 1 year ago

Hi,

in Berlin our data is organized in CRS EPSG:25833. We use Geoserver+WFS with appschema extension to provide reprojected data in CRS EPSG:3045/EPSG:4258. The CRS EPSG:25833 uses east-north axis order while EPSG:3045/EPSG:4258 use north-east axis order.

We observed that the INSPIRE validator accepts polygons in EPSG:25833 and the validator reports wrong polygon orientation for EPSG:3045/EPSG:4258 in test "gmlas.d.10: Validate Geometries (1)". The error messages in these cases are "Error detected: Invalid polygon. Outer ring of polygon is clockwise within element MultiSurface" and "Error detected: Invalid polygon. Inner ring of polygon is counterclockwise within element MultiSurface".

Other software (FME GeometryValidator testing simple features) does not report errors in polygon orientation in these CRS.

Test reports for EPSG:3045/25833 (via staging instance of validator):

plu_entwicklung - epsg 3045.zip plu_entwicklung - epsg 25833.zip

Links to the data:

Data in EPSG:3045

Data in EPSG:25833

Best regards & many thanks Damian

fabiovinci commented 1 year ago

Dear @ulbrichtd,

thank you for opening the issue and providing the related resources and sorry for the late reply.

This is a known issue for which we are testing the related solution in the BETA instance of the validator.

We will use your sample datasets for further testing and report back on the results.

fabiovinci commented 1 year ago

Dear @ulbrichtd,

we introduced a fix in the beta instance for the EPSG:3045 reference system, so the datasets with this reference system pass the geometry test if the axis order is N-E (Lat-Lon) and the related polygons contain counterclockwise outer rings and clockwise inner rings.

Could you please test the provided solution?

ulbrichtd commented 1 year ago

Hi Fabio,

thank you. I tested with the data. The validator reports now correct polygon orientation for EPSG:3045/EPSG:4258.

Unfortunately, test "lu-gml.a.1: Land Use feature in dataset" fails in the beta instance. The same data passes this test in the production instance of the validator. Please see attached reports Beta_vs_production-epsg_3045.zip.

Best regards, Damian

fabiovinci commented 1 year ago

Dear @ulbrichtd,

thank you for the confirmation. The error in the Beta instance is due to a temporary issue related to the redirection, which will be fixed soon.

JohannaOtt commented 1 year ago

@fabiovinci Is that fix limited to LU or is there any chance that it also fixes the general issue in https://github.com/inspire-eu-validation/ets-repository/issues/60?

fabiovinci commented 1 year ago

Hi @JohannaOtt,

the fix available in the BETA instance is a general fix for the issue related to polygon orientation.

fabiovinci commented 1 year ago

The fix has been made available in the Staging environment and will be included in the v2023.2 release.