For Frankfurt Meeting - Githubissues

IPBES-Data / IPBES_TCA_Corpus

0 stars 1 forks source link

For Frankfurt Meeting #7

Closed rkrug closed 7 months ago

rkrug commented 8 months ago

Type of analysis.

Here are some suggestions, feel free to add/modify them
Global maps showing

[x] 1. The number of studies (e.g. per IPBES suregion) including transformative changes cases,
[x] 2. Spatial and temporal analysis of the number of studies
[ ] 3. Research topics (economics, social, biophysical, ILK),
[ ] 4. Scale (local, regional, national, indigenous territories, etc),
[ ] 5. Methods and indicators (monetary, biophysical, sociocultural) mainly used,
[x] #8

Other suggestions?

niamir commented 8 months ago

Also ratio of change from biome to anthromes

rkrug commented 8 months ago

As I see it, the remaining ones (except of the Habitats (6) rely on full text analysis @niamir - correct?

One could use all available sub-fields and manually sort them into clusters relating to 3 and possibly 5, and analyse the topics of each work (all or only the main topic?) @niamir any opinion on that?

niamir commented 8 months ago

for item 6 - we should calculate the ratio of change from Biomes to Anthromes and this goes beyond a specific habitat. I am fully booked these weeks, perhaps @yanisica could support me with the implementation.

niamir commented 8 months ago

For points 3-5 I would not open the box of text analysis, let alone full text analysis. That is too much for IPBES. Maybe we could give them some input using the OpenAlex topics/concepts for item 3 and maybe item 5, but item 4 is not worth the effort and time.

I fully agree with @rkrug suggestion on using sub-fields and manually sort them into clusters relating to 3 and possibly 5.

rkrug commented 8 months ago

Grouping of subfields into groups for 3 and 5: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ZCB_St2TQu_wL3yl1iN7Wxz5FERGxk-GZA0_2oGcRM0/edit?usp=sharing

vikireyes commented 8 months ago

Is there a way to check if the document refers to 1) conservation, 2) direct drivers of change, 3) indirect drivers of change, or 4) underlying causes? To be transformative it has to address, somehow, 3 and 4

rkrug commented 8 months ago

Hi @vikireyes I do not think that is easily to do without an exhaustive full text analysis - any comments @niamir ?