search

ISISComputingGroup / IBEX

Top level repository for IBEX stories
4 stars 2 forks source link

ZOOM: Oxford 7.5T Cryomagnet into IBEX #2593

Closed KathrynBaker closed 6 years ago

KathrynBaker commented 6 years ago

As a scientist on ZOOM I want to use the 7.5T magnet during the cycle starting on the 14th of November

Acceptance Criteria

  1. I am able to create blocks and interact with the 7.5T magnet in IBEX as I can in SECI - setting/reading the same values
kjwoodsISIS commented 6 years ago

From: Alba Venero, Diego (STFC,RAL,ISIS) Sent: 15 September 2017 11:24 To: Woods, Kevin (Tessella,RAL,ISIS) Cc: Baker, Kathryn (STFC,RAL,ISIS) Subject: RE: 7.5T magnet on ZOOM in Cylce 2017/03

Hi Kevin,

Yes, you are right it is the 7.5T magnet.

Cheers,

Diego

From: Woods, Kevin (Tessella,RAL,ISIS) Sent: 15 September 2017 11:05 To: Alba Venero, Diego (STFC,RAL,ISIS) Cc: Baker, Kathryn (STFC,RAL,ISIS) Subject: 7.5T magnet on ZOOM in Cylce 2017/03

Hi Diego,

Kathryn tells me you plan to use the “7T magnet” with IBEX in Cycle 2017/03.

On checking the sample environment pages, I see that there is no 7T magnet.
There is a 7.5T magnet - https://www.isis.stfc.ac.uk/Pages/75T-Magnet.aspx. I assume that’s the one you mean. Is that correct? (I want to be sure that we provide support for the right magnet).

Thanks,

Kevin

AdrianPotter commented 6 years ago
Tom-Willemsen commented 6 years ago

Impeded awaiting confirmation from Diego about exactly what he needs from this ticket. Kathryn is meeting with him tomorrow to discuss this.

KathrynBaker commented 6 years ago

I have checked with Deigo, and it is unlikely to be needed for next cycle now (this is in light of commissioning this cycle), and if it is available then it can be run without scripting options.

I will move this back into the backlog for the time being. If the work to integrate this is significant I will let someone who has a better idea of how significant decide if it needs to be re-proposed for the next sprint, otherwise I will re-propose it for the Christmas sprint if it will be needed in the February cycle.

Tom-Willemsen commented 6 years ago

Quick overview of what was discussed for this ticket (so that we don't have to rediscuss all of this next time):

The 7.5T magnet is made up of 3 devices in a rack:

There is also some ancillary equipment in the same rack, e.g. a Neocera, that we don't need to worry about as part of this ticket.

The three units in the rack are daisy chained together and fed into an ISIS "box" which presents a single serial interface to all three units (the units are then addressed).

The scientists sometimes want a very basic level of control (i.e. Input field strength, let the driver figure out all the other parameters), and sometimes they want very fine control (e.g. setting the PID parameters of the temperature controller.

From a discussion between @GDH-ISIS @FreddieAkeroyd @John-Holt-Tessella and myself we think the EPICS solution is:

The LvDCOM solution would involve LvDCOMing the following VIs:

If we only wanted the "basic" level of control we might be able to get away with only LvDCOMing the VIs marked with (*). However there are some issues to consider with LvDCOM as this might tightly couple the LvDCOM to the configuration of one particular beamline.

The final issue to consider is that this equipment is being phased out over the timescale of ~1 year, so if we do put the effort in to write a full EPICS solution, it may not necessarily see much use before the equipment is retired.

(Note: If anything in this comment is wrong/missing, please do edit it and/or make corrections below.)

ChrisM-S commented 6 years ago

I cannot believe that all those individual pieces of Oxford Kit are being replaced everywhere within one year? But even so I expect we will find some of these components on other IBEX conversions (or arriving on some current ones). If I'm way out of date and we will never see and ITC or ILM in use after Sept 29 2018 I'm happy to be corrected not sure whether to :joy: or :cry: !

kjwoodsISIS commented 6 years ago

From: Howells, Gareth (STFC,RAL,ISIS) Sent: 27 September 2017 14:24 To: Akeroyd, Freddie (STFC,RAL,ISIS); Willemsen, Thomas (Tessella,RAL,ISIS); Holt, John (Tessella,RAL,ISIS); Woods, Kevin (Tessella,RAL,ISIS) Subject: FW: 7T magnet on Zoom

Dear All,

After talking with Diego, the 7T cryomagnet for Zoom will not be installed this cycle. When I pushed further, he did not sound convinced it would be next cycle either – they have other problems. I mentioned to him that if he decides to put the 7T magnet on to contact ASAP so that we are aware. Please see Diego’s email below.

Regards,

Gareth

From: Alba Venero, Diego (STFC,RAL,ISIS) Sent: 27 September 2017 14:15 To: Woods, Kevin (Tessella,RAL,ISIS) Cc: Howells, Gareth (STFC,RAL,ISIS) Subject: 7T magnet on Zoom

Hi Kevin,

We are not going to install the 7T cryomagnet in Zoom during this cycle. I scheduled it but after some discussion with Richard Down and Kathryn Baker we decide to postpone it. I then removed it from the scheduler, but it seems that the second part didn’t arrive to you.

Apologies and thank you very much,

Diego

KathrynBaker commented 6 years ago

Not certain this should be awaiting, we haven't done anything with it yet so am going to move this back to the backlog for suggesting when the time is right.

KathrynBaker commented 6 years ago

Re-proposing in March 2018, Asked for the April cycle, but accepting that it may not be available in IBEX (and therefore scriptable) until the 5th of June cycle.

FreddieAkeroyd commented 6 years ago

Emulator #3075

Tom-Willemsen commented 6 years ago

I haven't tested against the hardware but I think the review can be started against the following (some changes may be required when I get access to the hardware).

emulator and tests in #3075 should probably be reviewed at the same time

GDH-ISIS commented 6 years ago

Hardware has now been arranged so that the ioc can be tested. Located on top of LET. Tom informed. LET MOXA has had the accessible IP addresses disabled so that TOM can gain access to the hardware. I will re-instate the accessibility settings for LET again when it is closer to cycle.