search

ISO-TC211 / ISO19110

Revision of ISO19110
0 stars 0 forks source link

Requirement for FC_PropertyType #16

Closed jetgeo closed 8 years ago

jetgeo commented 9 years ago

section 6.2.2. The only required property on FC_PropertyType is memberName; this is not consistent with the requirement "The feature catalogue SHALL include definitions and descriptions of all feature attributes and feature associations.." Why definition and description-- none of the classes have both of these properties, and how are they distinguished?

jetgeo commented 9 years ago

Cardinality is also mandatory. But I agree, description is not an attribute on these classes. Definition is mandatory if not provided by definition source, so one may say that one is OK. Suggested change: "The feature catalogue SHALL include definitions of all feature attributes and feature associations.." The same change should also be applied to the requirement before this one: "The feature catalogue SHALL include definitions and descriptions of all feature types contained in the data"

Also, the requirements list (6.3) must be updated according to this.

DaveDanko commented 9 years ago

I'm getting lost in all these different lists of changes and what's been fixed but shouldn't "definition" in FC_FeatureType be mandatory?

jetgeo commented 9 years ago

Definition for FC_FeatureType is mandatory through the constraint. It shall either be provided through a definition source, or in the definition attribute.

jetgeo commented 9 years ago

...and I can understand your confusion, Dave. I was beginning to get lost myself, so I tried to collect all known issues in this list. Sorry if it made thing even worse :).

DaveDanko commented 9 years ago

thanks, I forgot to check constraints

DaveDanko commented 9 years ago

I made these changes to 6.2.2: Req/type-definitions: The feature catalogue SHALL include definitions and descriptions of all feature types contained in the data, Req/property-definitions: The feature catalogue SHALL include definitions and descriptions of all feature attributes and feature associations contained in the data that are associated withcatalogue each feature type. (attributes and assoc are optional but if included must have definitions) bold = delete; italic = added

jetgeo commented 8 years ago

I believe this is ok now.