search

ISO-TC211 / ISO19110

Revision of ISO19110
0 stars 0 forks source link

Encoding - reference to 19103, 19115 and 19139 #22

Closed jetgeo closed 8 years ago

jetgeo commented 9 years ago

Figure C.1 in the HM model is not identical to the one in the document. In the model, references goes to ISO19103:2005 (gco), ISO19115:2006 (gmd) and 19139 (gmx). In the document, the version of the referenced standards are left out. Suggested change:

DaveDanko commented 9 years ago

Our problem is that this document was written before ISO1115-3 existed. it references 19139 and uses the gmx namespace which is not used in 19115-3 (replaced by cat and others?). also on the http://standards.iso.org/iso/19110/ there is the addition of fcc which is not used/referenced in this document. I propose that this document be written to work with both 39 and 15-3 if possible. Annex C should have two parts one using 19139 (gmo, gmx, gco) and the other 19115-3. Can we add 19115-3 to the references even though it is not an IS? Steve/Ted can you help?

DaveDanko commented 9 years ago

forget my suggestion above - Annex C needs to be completely rewritten - referencing only the encoding rules in 19139 but implementing 19115-3 and using all new name spaces - abstract classes could also be added here solving Steve's issue #21

Steve or Ted would be the best ones to do that.

jetgeo commented 8 years ago

The whole package "Encoding Description" should be removed from the conceptual model. Implementation specific models should be in the implementation model(s). If there shall be any figure in Annex C for illustrating the encoding, we should use the "Package dependencies" figures from the implementation model.

jetgeo commented 8 years ago

Deleted encoding package from the conceptual model in EA. Still some work left on Annex C, but closing this issue.