search

ISO-TC211 / StandardsTracker

This GitHub repository lets you - our users - log and track issues that you find with our standards and other document. Tag the issue with the standard or standards effected; we will assign it to the relevant group(s) within TC 211.
12 stars 0 forks source link

Harmonize with other standards #166

Open isotc211 opened 3 years ago

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

Justification: Final report from Ad Hoc group on Location Based Services (N5110) Proposal: ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

ISO 19141(Moving features) and ISO 19116 (Positioning services) can decide what to do in terms of harmonizing with existing standards

ReesePlews commented 1 year ago

from N5900:

Comment: ISO 19141 defines a standard method to describe the geometry of a moving and ISO 19116 defines the data structure and content of an interface in positioning service.

Proposal: It seems difficult to harmonize these two standards as their scope is significantly different; At this time, we will not do any harmonization, but we would be open to any ideas on how this could be achieved in the future.

No ideas were received after the presentation (N5900) or during the ballot (N5920); this comment will not be addressed during the Ed3 Revision and should be deferred to another discussion;

the comment can remain open in my opinion; 19141 has been tagged to this comment;

ReesePlews commented 11 months ago

The 19116 Revision was completed (N5960) and sent to ISO/CS 2023-11-30. The DIS ballot will start 2024-01-18 and ends 2024-04-11.