search

ISO-TC211 / StandardsTracker

This GitHub repository lets you - our users - log and track issues that you find with our standards and other document. Tag the issue with the standard or standards effected; we will assign it to the relevant group(s) within TC 211.
11 stars 0 forks source link

difficulties implementing the new ISO 19103 Record #352

Open isotc211 opened 3 years ago

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

Justification: We are facing some difficulties implementing the new ISO 19103 Record. Here are some comments/questions: Proposal: Fix the documentation & modelling errors. Consider how to add e.g. measure to the record / field

isotc211 commented 3 years ago

(Received by email from Marie Lambois) 1- (easy and editorial one) documentation in Field_Type are incorrect and have typos. 2- In 19103, type (between field and FieldType) is 0 to 1 whereas in the schema it is 1 to many :

3- When a Record is implemented, the link to the FieldType is in fact encoded twice (once through the RecordType and once through the Field). Should we keep this redundant implementation ? In the example below I have tried not to duplicate. 4- In metadata, Records are often used with Measures (at least in my experience, here in georeferencedParameters). This new implementation makes the declaration of the unit of measure not easy. Should we have guidance ?

Sun elevation in degrees Measure 34
isotc211 commented 3 years ago

(Received by email from Marie Lambois) 1- (easy and editorial one) documentation in Field_Type are incorrect and have typos. 2- In 19103, type (between field and FieldType) is 0 to 1 whereas in the schema it is 1 to many :

3- When a Record is implemented, the link to the FieldType is in fact encoded twice (once through the RecordType and once through the Field). Should we keep this redundant implementation ? In the example below I have tried not to duplicate. 4- In metadata, Records are often used with Measures (at least in my experience, here in georeferencedParameters). This new implementation makes the declaration of the unit of measure not easy. Should we have guidance ?

Sun elevation in degrees Measure 34
heidivanparys commented 2 months ago

Record is not present any more in ISO/FDIS 19103, this should be transfered to HMMG (management of the new “common types” package).