This GitHub repository lets you - our users - log and track issues that you find with our standards and other document. Tag the issue with the standard or standards effected; we will assign it to the relevant group(s) within TC 211.
11
stars
0
forks
source link
Unresolved terminology issues in ISO 19126:2021 #426
The attached comments (2021-04-26) are for the 19126 FDIS. There was a mistake by TMG in understanding the schedule and the comments were not submitted before the ballot closed and the document was sent to ISO/CS for publication. TMG has always submitted comments, if needed, during the FDIS stage, and those comments shall be addressed before the document advances to the final stage. Some of the comments (shown below) are significant and related to the revision ISO 19131. If, for other reasons, an amendment is proposed, these terminology issues should be addressed.
term-no| term | cmnt-type| comment | TMG recommendation |
-- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
3.0 | various entries | Ed | inconsistent use of commas in source references; in source references that contain modification notes, a comma should be placed after the term number and before the "modified" descriptive note; some entries in the document do this correctly while other entries do not. | in the source reference add a comma after the term number and before "modified" for the following entries: 3.6, 3.13, 3.15, 3.17, 3.22 |
3.2 | data product | Ed | this entry correctly matches ISO 19131:2007 however the revision of ISO 19131 (currently pending publication) has changed the definition between the DIS and FDIS | TMG prefers to use the original definition of ISO 19131:2007 and will discuss with ISO 19131 Rev. editor. TMG also recommends aligning terminology in both standards (ISO 19126 and ISO 19131) seeing that publication is pending. |
3.3 | data product specification | Ed | this entry correctly matches ISO 19131:2007 however the revision of ISO 19131 (currently pending publication) has changed the definition between the DIS and FDIS | TMG prefers to use the original definition of ISO 19131:2007 and will discuss with ISO 19131 Rev. editor. TMG also recommends aligning terminology in both standards (ISO 19126 and ISO 19131) seeing that publication is pending. |
3.7 | feature association concept | Ed | issue regarding "can" vs "may" ; changed between DIS to FDIS stage; TMG prefers to keep the original ISO 19126 IS definition that used "may" and was originally accepted by ISO | TMG will discuss directly with ISO/CS about this entry |
3.9 | feature attribute concept | Ed | issue regarding "can" vs "may" ; changed between DIS to FDIS stage; TMG prefers to keep the original ISO 19126 IS definition that used "may" and was originally accepted by ISO | TMG will discuss directly with ISO/CS about this entry |
3.10 | feature catalogue | Ed | issue regarding "can" vs "may" ; changed between DIS to FDIS stage; TMG prefers to keep the original ISO 19126 IS definition that used "may" and was originally accepted by ISO | TMG will discuss directly with ISO/CS about this entry |
3.11 | feature concept | Ed | issue regarding "can" vs "may" ; changed between DIS to FDIS stage; TMG prefers to keep the original ISO 19126 IS definition that used "may" and was originally accepted by ISO | TMG will discuss directly with ISO/CS about this entry |
3.12 | feature concept dictionary | Ed | issue regarding "can" vs "may" ; changed between DIS to FDIS stage; TMG prefers to keep the original ISO 19126 IS definition that used "may" and was originally accepted by ISO | TMG will discuss directly with ISO/CS about this entry |
3.14 | feature operation concept | Ed | issue regarding "can" vs "may" ; changed between DIS to FDIS stage; TMG prefers to keep the original ISO 19126 IS definition that used "may" and was originally accepted by ISO | TMG will discuss directly with ISO/CS about this entry |
3.15 | hierarchical register | Ed | for consistency, revise the note on the source reference for grammar and punctuation | change: [SOURCE: ISO 19135‑1:2015, 4.1.4 modified — Example updated] to: [SOURCE: ISO 19135‑1:2015, 4.1.4 modified — The Example has been updated.] |
The attached comments (2021-04-26) are for the 19126 FDIS. There was a mistake by TMG in understanding the schedule and the comments were not submitted before the ballot closed and the document was sent to ISO/CS for publication. TMG has always submitted comments, if needed, during the FDIS stage, and those comments shall be addressed before the document advances to the final stage. Some of the comments (shown below) are significant and related to the revision ISO 19131. If, for other reasons, an amendment is proposed, these terminology issues should be addressed.