search

Idorobots / mode-line-stats

A bunch of easy to set up stats for the Emacs mode-line.
25 stars 8 forks source link

mls-toggle-key is unused. #10

Open Idorobots opened 10 years ago

Idorobots commented 10 years ago

With the upcomming update that adds the :buffer related stuff we no longer need mls-toggle-key to switch between :primary and :secondary formats. Perhaps it could be replaced with another buffer-related command?

agpchil commented 10 years ago

I forgot to say this early but the :buffer feature is a WorkInProgress! Like almost everything in the experimental branch :)

I think the mls-toggle-key should be used to switch between current-buffer and mls :buffer now. But probably we should rename the variable with a better name too :)

agpchil commented 10 years ago

@Idorobots Does it make sense to have a keymap in mls just to switch to mls-buffer? Maybe we could remove this keymap and let the user define his own key bind to whatever he wants (in his .emacs.d config file)?

For example:

(global-set-key (kbd "C-c m") 'mls-buffer-show)

But with the new mls-buffer I think it makes more sense to have a major mode in mls-buffer instead, to do some actions:

Idorobots commented 10 years ago

@agpchil I think we can drop the keymap, it's best to leave mls-buffer-show for the users to use as they please.

On the other hand, major mode for the mls-buffer could be fairly useful. An easy way to manage various modules and their formats could be very handy. I'm thinking something in the vein of short, single-letter Org-Agenda commands. For example, n to move to the next stat, u to force-update it, e and d to enable/disable modules. Any thoughts?

agpchil commented 10 years ago

@Idorobots I agree with that.

I'll try to do this changes and add the major-mode and some basic actions but I probably won't implement all the features for now (like enable/disable modules).

agpchil commented 9 years ago

@Idorobots I did some testing and to be able to add the navigation stuff, filters, control, etc. we'll need to make a lot of custom code and it will be hard to maintain data consistency...

I think we should re-think the mls-buffer view. IMHO using something like Tabulated List mode should be a better option (and maybe easier to add the features we want).

Idorobots commented 9 years ago

@agpchil, offloading mls-buffer structuring & navigation to an external mode sounds reasonable, but it would be nice to leave a way for the users to change Tabulated List mode to something else if they want to (Org-Mode/Org-Agenda maby? :)). I think that defaulting modules' formatters to Tabulated List mode specific formats is ok, but we shouldn't ship mls with Tabulated List mode as a hard dependency. What do you think about it?

agpchil commented 9 years ago

I think Tabulated list mode is shipped with emacs 24 already so I don't think it's a hard dependency...

Can you give me more details about the org-* use case? I don't understand why the user would want to change the major mode when mls-buffer already use its own.

I think if someone wants a different view of mls they should write an specific mode for that or just call some mls internals to to that. Should we ship mls with a few different view modes?