search

InTaVia / source-dataset-conversion

scripts and converted datasets accordng to IDM RDF (see IDM RDF repository)
0 stars 0 forks source link

How to serialize coordinates for places #2

Open CarlaVS opened 2 years ago

CarlaVS commented 2 years ago

We have coordinates for places in different InTaVia datasets.

My suggestion to serialize them (according to ISO 6709) with the P168 place is defined by property is:

<https://www.intavia.org/apis/place/3162> a crm:E53_Place ;
    crm:P168_place_is_defined_by "46.76667 23.6" ;

We could also split the lat and long in two values or add the information which one is latitude and longitude. I think in this case the most simple solution is the best one.

razz0 commented 2 years ago

An issue with this is that it's not clear from the data that ISO 6709 is used. For machine readability this information would need to be conveyed somewhere.

One simple alternative solution would be to use the Basic Geo Vocabulary which is already in use in BiographySampo. But this is of course not directly compatible with CIDOC CRM.

sennierer commented 2 years ago

What about geosparql from OGC? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OGC_GeoSPARQL

geo:hasGeometry _:node1g02elp9ox8232762 .

_:node1g02elp9ox8232762 geo:asWKT "Point ( +016.371690 +048.208199 )"^^geo:wktLiteral;
  a sf:Point .

as eg the GND is using it: https://d-nb.info/gnd/4066009-6/about/lds.ttl

sennierer commented 2 years ago

Just to note that here: ISO 6709 as mentioned by @CarlaVS and WKT have a different sequence of coordinates. lat long (ISO 6709) vs long lat (WKT)

CarlaVS commented 2 years ago

Update: Decided to use Cidoc CRM/ wkt Literal solution. See: https://github.com/InTaVia/source-dataset-conversion/blob/67f2639095225e946388bf3c384758f90814032b/APIS_dataset/apis_conversion_cidoc7.1.1.py .

The order of coordinates is "POINT Longitude Latitude". Be careful and check twice in you code (see comment above).

CarlaVS commented 2 years ago

Example from the current solution:

http://www.intavia.eu/apis/place/3162 a crm:E53_Place ; crm:P168_place_is_defined_by http://www.intavia.eu/apis/spaceprimitive/3162 ; crm:P1_is_identified_by http://www.intavia.eu/apis/placeappellation/3162/Klausenburg, http://www.intavia.eu/apis/placeidentifier/3162 ; owl:sameAs https://apis.acdh.oeaw.ac.at/apis/api/entities/place/3162/, https://sws.geonames.org/681290/ .

http://www.intavia.eu/apis/spaceprimitive/3162 a crm:E94_Space_Primitive ; crm:P168_place_is_defined_by "POINT 23.6 46.76667"^^geo:wktLiteral .