Inria-Empenn / narps_open_pipelines

A codebase reproducing the 70 pipelines of the NARPS study (Botvinik-Nezer et al., 2020) shared as an open resource for the community.
MIT License
9 stars 22 forks source link

[DC61] Pipeline reproduction (SPM - deriv) #157

Open mgaubert opened 5 months ago

mgaubert commented 5 months ago

Softwares

Software: SPM

Input data

derivatives (fMRIprep)

Additional context

Test SPM batch of the team

List of tasks

Please tick the boxes below once the corresponding task is finished. :+1:

cmaumet commented 5 months ago

@mgaubert: I am adding you as assignee on this issue just for the time of the hackathon so that we can more easily see which pipelines are awaiting contributors in https://github.com/orgs/Inria-Empenn/projects/1/views/1

bclenet commented 3 months ago

Hi @cmaumet,

Here is a quick question about this analysis. In the inference_contrast_effect section, the description mentions:

Second level contrasts for the gain analysis :

  • ‘gain_param_indiff’: T-contrast of parametric effect of gain in the equal indifference group
    • [1 0] i.e. 1gain_param_indiff
  • ‘gain_param_range’: T-contrast of parametric effect of gain in the equal range group
    • [0 1] i.e. 1gain_param_range

Does this mean that we design a one sample t-test with two covariates, one for the equalRange, another for the equalIndifference group ? And we pass subject-level contrasts files from both groups as input ?

cmaumet commented 3 months ago

@bclenet: I confirm that I think you have the right answer to this!

bclenet commented 3 months ago

Hi @cmaumet,

Later in the description (also in the inference_contrast_effect section):

Second level contrasts for the loss analysis :

  • 'loss_param_indiff': F-contrast of parametric effect of loss in the equal indifference group
    • [1 0] i.e. 1loss_param_indiff
  • 'loss_param_range': F-contrast of parametric effect of loss in the equal range group
    • [0 1] i.e. 1loss_param_range

I assume they actually used F-contrasts here (probably not a typo), but could you please let me know how their setup in SPM is different from the one of a t-contrast ?

cmaumet commented 3 months ago

We looked at the collection on NV: https://neurovault.org/collections/4963/ and we confirmed that gain was a T-contrast and loss an F-contrast.