International-Data-Spaces-Association / IDS-RAM_4_0

Focusing on the generalization of concepts, functionality, and overall processes involved in the creation of a secure 'network of trusted data' , the IDS-RAM resides at a higher abstraction level than common architecture models of concrete software solutions do. The document provides an overview and dedicated architecture specifications.
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
38 stars 27 forks source link

Restructure Chapter 3 #112

Closed HeinrichPet closed 1 year ago

HeinrichPet commented 2 years ago

We want to write about Policy Negotiation and Policy Enforcement in chapter 3.3 Process Layer. The goal is to write how Policy Negotiation between Connectors takes place, and how some policies start processes to get data from Policy Information Points, etc..

However, we see the problem that contracts are only described in the following chapter 3.4 Information Layer. In the Information Layer also the Self-Description is defined, which is already used in the 3.3.2 Data Offering chapter.

Basically, we think that the Informaiton layer should be before the communication (in our case process) layer. Logically, we should always first define what we are communicating and then how you are doing it: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smart_Grid_Architecture_Model.

Any opinions to that?

@sebbader @ssteinbuss @juliapampus @Brandstaedter @clange

juliapampus commented 2 years ago

I would also propose to swap the sections 3.3.5 and 3.3.6. I think this app topic is an optional thing and we should've talked about policy enforcement in general, before talking about apps, and then also about somehow extended usage control/policy enforcement.

Brandstaedter commented 2 years ago

Hi, I assigned you @juliapampus @HeinrichPet @hosseinzadeha . We should do a short alignement meeting about 30min, to avoid repeats.

juliapampus commented 2 years ago

Will you send a mail @Brandstaedter?

HeinrichPet commented 2 years ago

We should also include @clange for the information layer and optionally @ssteinbuss for overall alignment.

HeinrichPet commented 2 years ago

WG Architecture agreed on restructuring chapter 3 by swapping the Information Layer with the Process Layer in the WG Architecture meeting March 15th.

ssteinbuss commented 1 year ago

Closed by #193