International-Data-Spaces-Association / IDSA-Rulebook

The working repository of the IDSA Rulebook Working Group
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
12 stars 3 forks source link

Role definitions to be synchronized with DSSC #19

Closed turpema closed 1 day ago

turpema commented 1 year ago

Some key roles, for example Data Holder, are not mentioned in the role descriptions. Needs to be synchronized with DSSC documents, including DSSC Glossary definitions.

ssteinbuss commented 8 months ago

The IDSA Rulebook describes some role models in the section Guiding Principles. We could add the definitions from the Glossary section "Legal definitions regarding European data economy concepts", at least:

This should also include a mapping of which of those roles are considered to be a participant in a data space and which are not considered to be a participant in a data space.

This also relates to issues #21 and #25

This can also include a kind of mapping between the different definitions and comparing those to a certain extent.

ssteinbuss commented 8 months ago

The Data space governance framework in the DSSC Blueprint is similar to the membership policies in the section on policies. This also holds true for the "Policies and rules" in the section on creating a data space. Should we align this with the Blueprint?

ssteinbuss commented 8 months ago

Further roles to be discussed in this context are from DSSC Blueprint section 4.2:

ssteinbuss commented 8 months ago

In general, the IDSA Rulebook lacks of a clear definition of a participant and the subsequent sub-roles. This should be included.

ssteinbuss commented 8 months ago

IDSA Rulebook does not describe in detail ecosystem service like explained in section 4.5 in the DSSC Blueprint. We might want to update IDSA Rulebook section onoptional functions.

ssteinbuss commented 8 months ago

DSSC Blueprint Glossary has in section 4.8 Data Policies and Contracts some definitions, which should be aligned with the IDSA Rulebook section on Policies.

ssteinbuss commented 8 months ago

DSSC Blueprint Glossary in section 4.9. on identity and Trust should be aligned with our definitions in "Establising Trust"

viivilahteenoja commented 8 months ago

For reference, my work-in-progress glossary harmonisation exercise can be viewed here: https://airtable.com/app0PIxiDKt2XocA2/shrR0aceTswrZDmxN

turpema commented 8 months ago

Another term to be synced is "Data space authority" in IDSA Rulebook vs. "Data space governance authority" in DSSC Glossary 2.0

ssteinbuss commented 8 months ago

Another term to be synced is "Data space authority" in IDSA Rulebook vs. "Data space governance authority" in DSSC Glossary 2.0

We also need to update the figures accordingly.

ssteinbuss commented 1 day ago

This is already implemented