search

Islandora / documentation

Contains islandora's documentation and main issue queue.
MIT License
104 stars 71 forks source link

Drupal Collections and Fedora Containment #381

Closed whikloj closed 6 years ago

whikloj commented 8 years ago

This issue is to discuss all opinions thoughts and questions around how we want to deal with collections and the objects inside once move from Drupal to Fedora.

Currently all items will be under (LDP contained by) an islandora:root object.

Resources (both RDF and NonRDF) will not necessarily be LDP contained by any collections they are a member of.

DiegoPino commented 8 years ago

I don't want to repeat myself, since there is a lot of stuff i already said in IRC i will paste current/past state of the discussion here: http://irclogs.islandora.ca/2016-09-26.html

dannylamb commented 8 years ago

Out of that IRC conversation, did we ever agree on collection membership being required?

DiegoPino commented 8 years ago

@dannylamb at least not in a call i was part of. I feel we said it was desired to keep (re-implement and code is a better expression) the islandora 1.x idea on collection membership, but i don't think we should impose it. Moreover islandora 1.x does allow orphan children. Our children could be at most/at least not part of a collection but still be, semantically speaking, part of the LDP tree and contained.

whikloj commented 8 years ago

Due to performance implications the default triplestore indexing does not index ldp:contains. The recommendation is to use fedora:hasParent, pcdm:memberOf or this type of property.

This removes the usefulness of the ldp:indirectContainer.

Therefore it is probably a good idea to dump the /members indirect container inside Collections and instead add a user configurable predicate (defaulting to pcdm:memberOf, dcmi:isPartOf ??) to the Collection module configuration and add it to any object added to the collection.

Death to Proxies!!

dannylamb commented 8 years ago

:+1: Let's use the CMS and its relational database to let users manage relationships. Just flush it to Fedora as triples. No need for anything else.

Using the inverse relationships will make everything easier for SQL too. Can't wait 'til the collection view is actually a Drupal view.

dannylamb commented 6 years ago

Resolved via https://github.com/Islandora-CLAW/islandora/commit/a1987aecb747b0b297176fc4d34afdc22cbddb4d