search

Isurwars / Correlation

This program calculates the main correlation functions of a material: Radial Distribution Function (J(r)), Pair Distribution Function (g(r)) and Plane Angle Distribution (PAD).
MIT License
17 stars 7 forks source link

Software paper review #8

Closed awvwgk closed 3 years ago

awvwgk commented 3 years ago

This is issue is part of the review in https://github.com/openjournals/joss-reviews/issues/2976, focusing on the software paper.

The paper itself is well-written and compares mainly against proprietary trajectory analyzers. The software is proposed as open source alternative to those proprietary programs. The paper does not compare to existing open source implementations for trajectory analysis. A non-comprehensive list of open source trajectory analyzers is given below:

Those projects should be mentioned and compared to this project.

Isurwars commented 3 years ago

I will incorporate the comparison within the next version of the paper/software.