search

JADE-V-V / JADE

JADE, a novel nuclear data libraries V&V tool
GNU General Public License v3.0
23 stars 8 forks source link

[Feature request] - No correspondence between openmc and mcnp tally numbers and descriptions for Sphere Leakage benchmark #282

Closed dodu94 closed 5 months ago

dodu94 commented 5 months ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. At the moment, as shown by the raw .csv data, the tally number and description are not consistent between MCNP and OpenMC. This creates issues with the JADE web app, but also I believe it would complicate the cross code comparison capabilities that need to be implemented in JADE

image

Moreover, it appears that a normalization factor has been applied to the OpenMC results, impeding a proper comparison: image

Describe the solution you'd like Conform the tally number and description to the ones of MCNP also for OpenMC, since no production run of OpenMC has been run yet.

dodu94 commented 5 months ago

Actually not applicable, the tallies are not comparable since OpenMC has been implemented as total flux in the sphere and not leakage