Could formalizing or codifying some of these validation processes accomplish the same as peer-review or more?

JEK-III / DPLandscapePaper

Data Publication Landscape Paper

0 stars 0 forks source link

Could formalizing or codifying some of these validation processes accomplish the same as peer-review or more? #37

Closed JEK-III closed 10 years ago

JEK-III commented 10 years ago

Yes. Make that a clearer statement.

JEK-III commented 10 years ago

Researchers trust peer review in part because they understand the process and its limitations; if researchers come to understand them, alternate pre- or post-publication validation processes could potentially provide the same level of assurance.