JavGVastro / PhD.Paper

This repository contains updated methods for the project H II regions Structure functions (previously CSHR).
0 stars 2 forks source link

Fix to treatment of finite map effect #6

Closed will-henney closed 2 years ago

will-henney commented 2 years ago

While reviewing the section of the paper on the model structure function, I came to the conclusion that the way we were dealing with the finite map size was not right.

The equation A1 for beta(r0) is fine, but it does not make sense to apply this to the sigma^2 and r0 parameters in the model structure function. Instead, it gives the reduction in the empirically determined sigma^2 and r0, but this is purely because of truncation of the large scales, not because of any change in the strucfunc at a given separation.

Note that the curves in Fig A1 are all exactly the same in the ranges where they overlap.

Therefore, we should go back to bfunc03s instead of bfunc04s.

I have edited all the CI*.ipynb notebooks to reflect this, and have re-run them.