JayQine / AMR

Apache License 2.0
63 stars 6 forks source link

Why do u apply anti-adv method to generate initial cam seeds, I reproduce your implementation and find that your real initial cam seeds are worse than baseline without anti-adv method? Can u explain this? #4

Open TyroneLi opened 2 years ago

TyroneLi commented 2 years ago

Maybe, this paper propose no new methods for WSSS. Your improvement is brought by cvpr2020 anti-adv method.

JayQine commented 2 years ago

It is an auxiliary module for generating cams. If you want to perform our method in another mode, maybe you should readjust the hyper-parameters.

TyroneLi commented 2 years ago

To be fair, applying your method to baseline, the cams quality becomes worse while I try to reproduce. But implementing anti-Adv the cams quality becomes better than baseline, but noting that this improvement does not come from your method. I am so confused why your method works for nothing even hampering the performance. because your method is just for paper writing but works nothing??? Hope you can explain and re-implement your released code for right reproducement

TyroneLi commented 2 years ago

What I want to say is that the story A works for nothing but just for paper writing while story B actually works but it has already been published, and you just steal it from others??