Mistakes in scores

[Mick1303]

This is the thread for score discrepancies:

In 2021 tokyo Olympics you have 3 matches where tie-break scores are missing. Winner;Loser;Round;Score Pablo Carreno-Busta; Dominik Koepfer;R16;7-6(7) 6-3 Ilya Ivashka; Mikhail Kukushkin;R32;6-7(4) 6-3 6-3 Marcos Giron; Norbert Gombos,R64;7-6(4) 3-6 6-2

In Wimbledon 21 in the score for Otte-Rinderknech in R128 final set tb score is missing. Shall be 4-6,6-3,6-2,6-7(5),13-12(2).

In Wimbledon 19 in the score for Djokovic-Federer the final tb score is missing. Shall be 7-6(5),1-6,7-6(4),4-6,13-12(3)

In RG 2020 R32 Grigor Dimitrov - Carballes Baena shall say 6-1,6-3;ret. rather than 6-1,6-3,0-0.

Davis Cup WG PO 2012: BRA vs RUS: Rogerio Dutra Silva-Igor Andreev shall say 6-2,6-1;ret. rather than 6-2,6-1,0-0.

Davis Cup WG R1: GER vs ESP 2014 Feliciano Lopez- Philipp Kohlschreiber DC site says w/o rather than 0-0 (latter implies that the play started).

In RG 2020 R32 Stefanos Tsitsipas - Bedene "Ret." is missing in the score.

It will be a low priority thread, because generally I'm switching to WTA syncing. But from time to time I will revisit this one.

[Mick1303]

You have Atlanta WCT 1974 R32 Graebner-Stewart with a score 6-4,3-6,6-4. ATP and ITF both have it 6-4,3-6,6-1

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Toronto WCT 1974 (1974-302) F Okker-Nastase ATP has 6-3,6-4. ITF has 7-6,6-2 SF Okker-Alexander ATP has 7-6(3),6-2. ITF has 6-3,6-4 also here you have R32 Dominguez-McManus as unknown score, while ATP and ITF have 7-5,2-6,6-3

[js] newspapers confirm ATP is right on the SF/F scores

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Australian Open 1974 R16 Connors-Ball ATP has 6-4,5-7,6-7,6-3,6-4. ITF has 6-4,5-7,6-3,6-4. also here you have R32 Parun-Feaver 4-6,6-3,7-6,8-6, while both ATP and ITF have it 4-6,4-6,6-3,7-6,8-6 also here ATP does not have result for R32 N'Godrella-Caujolle, while ITF has it 6-3,7-5,6-3

[js] newspapers agree with the ATP Connors score

[Mick1303]

In 2009 Wimbledon there are couple of TB sets scores without points - in Acasuso R128 and Haas R128 matches. Those are both 7-6(0).

[Mick1303]

2008 YEC. Davydenko-Tsonga. TB score was 7-6(0) 2008 Moscow. Mathieu-Sela. TB score was 7-6(0)

[Mick1303]

In the match DelPo-Schuettler in 2008 Hertogenbosch there is a discrepancy in scores between ATP - 7-6(3),4-3 and ITF - 7-6(3),7-6(5). https://www.itftennis.com/en/tournament/s-hertogenbosch/ned/2008/m-is-ned-01a-2008/draws-and-results/. ATP does not even mention retirement. Possibly a typo on ATP part?

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Quebec 1973 SF Riessen-Johansson ATP has 6-4,6-3. ITF has 6-4,6-1 R16 Johansson-Borg ATP has 6-2,6-2. ITF has invalid score 7-2,6-2 also here you have QF Johansson-Graebner 6-3,6-2, while both ATP and ITF have it 6-3,6-3

[js] newspaper confirms 6-4 6-3 for Reissen

[Mick1303]

Error copied from ATP site: Miami 1999. Delgado - Schuettler.- 7-5(5),6-1 is invalid. ITF has 7-6(5),6-1.

[Mick1303]

Grand Slam cup 1998 imported from ATP site does not have TB scores. ITF has them.

[Mick1303]

There are discrepancy in some scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Australian Open 1998 R128 Rios-Stafford. ATP(&wiki) has 6-1,6-3,6-3, ITF has 6-1,6-0,6-3. R128 Spadea- Stasiak. ITF has 6-7(4),6-1,6-4,4-6,6-3, ATP has invalid score 6-7(4),6-1,6-4,4-6(3),6-3, while wiki has 6-7(4),6-1,6-4,6-7(3),6-3. R32 Berasategui- Rafter TB scores are missing (like on ATP site). Shall be 6-7(2),7-6(7),6-2,7-6(4). Both ITF and wiki have this score.

[js] newspapers agree with ITF on Spadea (4-6 in 4th), also confirm ITF on Rios-Stafford

[Mick1303]

Moscow 1997 R16 Kafelnikov-Black. ATP (and you) has invalid score 6-4(5),6-3. Shall be just 6-4,6-3 per ITF.

[Mick1303]

There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of Gstaad 1973 R32 Fairlie-Spear ATP has 6-3,1-6,9-8. ITF has 6-3,4-6,9-8 also you have R32 Emerson-Ovici 2-6,6-1,6-2, while both ATP and ITF have it 6-4,6-4

[js] can't find a newspaper report of Fairlie-Spear, so I'll keep the ATP score for now

[Mick1303]

You have Roland Garros 1973 R64 Phillips-Moore-Baranyi as 7-6,6-2, while both ATP and ITF have it 7-5,6-2 You have R64 Bertolucci-Cox as 7-5,6-2, while both ATP and ITF have it 7-5,6-3 There is a discrepancy in scores in the ITF version and ATP version of R64 Fillol-sr-Estep ATP has 6-3,7-6, ITF has 6-1,7-6 R128 Fillol-sr-Kelaidis ATP has 6-2,6-2, ITF has 6-2,6-4

[js] newspapers confirm ATP scores for both Fillol matches

[Mick1303]

Beijing 1997 R32 Rikl- Wheaton. ATP has invalid score 7-5,6-3(4). ITF has 7-5,6-3.

[Mick1303]

Amsterdam 1997 QF Filippini- Sanchez. ATP has invalid score 7-5(5),6-1. ITF has 7-6(5),6-1 Weirdly exactly the same incorrect score repeats in Umag 1997 R16 - Portas- Ljubicic

[Mick1303]

Monte Carlo 1997 R64 Philippoussis- Gumy. ATP has invalid score 7-5,7-5(5). ITF has 6-1,7-6. I don't remember where I imported this from, but I have 6-1,7-6(5).

[js] newspapers confirm your 6-1 7-6(5)

[Mick1303]

Barcelona 1997 R64 Alonso- Gustafsson. ATP has invalid score 6-3(6),6-4. ITF has 7-6,3-6,6-3. I don't remember where I imported this from, but I have 7-6(6),3-6,6-3.

[Mick1303]

Australian Open 1997 R64. Medvedev-Stich. ATP has invalid score 4-6,5-7,6-2,4-6,9-7. The winner lost more sets than the loser. ITF has 4-6,6-1,6-2,4-6,9-7.

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1996 Marbella quarter. Mantilla-Ruud ATP has invalid score 0-7, 7-6(2),6-3. You fixed it as 5-7, 7-6(2),6-3. ITF has 1st set as 0-6.

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1996 New Haven quarter. Siemerink- Krajicek with invalid score 6-4(3),6-4. Wiki has 7-6(3),6-4

[Mick1303]

Atlanta Olympics draw does not have the majority of TB scores. Wiki has them.

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1996 Rosmalen R32. Schalken- Black with invalid score 6-3,7-5(1). ITF has 6-3, 7-6.

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1996 Coral Springs R32. Tebbutt-Draper with invalid score 7-5(3),4-6,6-3. ITF has it 7-6,4-6,6-3

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1995 Lyon R32. Roux-Escude with invalid score 6-3,7-5(12). ITF has it 6-3,7-6 Reasonable to assume it was 6-3,7-6(12)

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1995 Beijing R32. Carlsen-Caratti with invalid score 6-4,7-5(5). ITF has it 6-4,7-6

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1995 San Marino R32. Dewulf-Musa with invalid score 7-6(4),7-5(5). ITF has it 7-6,7-6

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1995 Canadian R32. Steven- Krajicek with invalid score 7-5(7),3-1;ret. ITF has it 7-6,3-1;ret.

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1995 Bastad R32. Martinez-Engel with invalid score 1-6,6-2,7-5(1). ITF has it 1-6,6-2,7-6

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1994 Moscow R32. Martin-Holm with invalid score 7-5(2),7-6(6). ITF has it 7-6,7-6

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1994 Bogota R32. Tobon-Morejon with invalid score 7-5(3),6-7,6-1. ITF has it 7-5,6-7,6-1

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1994 Prague R32. Medvedev-Tramacchi with invalid score 7-5(6),6-0. ITF has it 7-6,6-0

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1994 Dubai R32. Gustafsson- Larsson with invalid score 6-4(4),7-6. ITF has it 7-6,6-3

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1993 Lyon R32. Barthez- Gorriz with invalid score 6-3,7-5(6). ITF has it 6-3,7-6

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1993 Halle R32. Leconte-Haarhuis with invalid score 5-7(5),6-3,6-2. ITF has it 6-7,6-3,6-2

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1993 Roland Garros R32. Haarhuis-Steeb with invalid score 7-5(3),6-3,6-1. ITF has it 7-6,6-3,6-1

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1993 Tampa SF. Fromberg- Shelton with invalid score 6-7(5),5-3,7-5. ITF has it 6-7,6-3,7-5

[JeffSackmann]

all caught up here -- thank you for all of these. I'll leave the issue open because surely there will be more.

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1992 Bordeaux R32. Chesnokov- Sanchez with invalid score 6-2(2),7-6. ITF has it 6-2,7-6

[Mick1303]

In Barcelona Olympics 92 draw two matches on ATP site have incomplete scores (they played bof5). Lavalle-Leconte - shall be 6-4,3-6,4-6,6-3,10-8 Oncins-Muskatirovic shall be 7-6,4-6,6-1,4-6,6-1. ITF has complete scores. Also ITF has all TB scores

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1992 Wimbledon R128. Kinnear-Steeb with incorrect score 7-6(6),2-6,6-7(7),6-1. The match can't be finished with 2-2 in sets. ITF score is 7-6(6),6-2,6-7(7),6-1.

[Mick1303]

Not clear how to assess Nottingham 1970 results. ITF does not have it (at least when I look 1970 activity of Stan Smith, who is the winner, it is not listed) ATP has it now as challenger only from QF (which is also questionable, because there was no challenger circuit back then). TennisArchives does have it, but with also some strange results. I do not remember where I imported it it from ( Now we have the following discrepancies: I have R64 Segal-McDonald 7-5,7-5, you have 6-3,7-5. TA has 3-5,7-5 (not helpful) I have R64 Steele III-Armytage 6-2,8-6, you have 6-2,7-6. No other occurrences of TB sets in this tourney, but plenty of 8-6 sets. I'll go with mine. TennisArchives has it the same as mine. I have R64 Wijono-Fawcett 3-6,6-3,7-5, you have 3-6,6-3,8-6. TennisArchives has it the same as mine Maybe I did import it from TA, just fixed 3-5 to 7-5, considering it most logical in the first match.

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1992 Maceio R32. Azar-Montana with invalid score 6-3(4),6-2. ITF has it 7-6,6-2

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1991 Lyon R16. Mancini-Kulti with invalid score 2-6(8),7-6,6-4. You fixed it to 7-6(8),7-6,6-4. But this tournament is best of 3. ITF score is 7-6,6-4

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1991 Athens QF Clavet-Jonsson 7-6(5),0-1 (no mention of retirement). ITF has it 7-6,6-1

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1991 Nice R16 Jaite-Arias with invalid score 6-2,6-1(4). ITF has it 6-2,7-6. Note - in all these cases I have the score as ITF, except the TB score is present and most always TB score is the same as ATP mistakenly attach to non-tb sets (which in reality indeed were TBs).

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1990 Itaparica R32. Motta-Roese with incomplete score 3-6,7-6(no mention of retirement). ITF has it 3-6,7-6,6-4

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1990 US Open R128. Ho-Odizor with incomplete score 6-2,4-6,6-2,3-6 (no mention of retirement). ITF has it 6-2,4-6,6-2,3-6,7-5

[Mick1303]

1990 New Haven R64. Goldie-Layendecker. Both ATP and ITF have identical invalid score 7-6,6-4,6-3. Since the tournament was Best of 3, the score 3-0 in sets is wrong here. I have 7-6,6-4. Did not keep tabs where I imported this from.

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1990 Washington R64. Ondruska-Baur with incomplete score 4-6,6-1 (no mention of retirement). ITF has it 4-6,6-1,6-0

[Mick1303]

ATP has 1990 Stuttgart Outdoor R32 Leconte-Windahl with invalid score 6-4,6-2,6-4 (draw was best of 3). ITF has it 6-4,6-2