JerrZzzz / The-Glamour-Of-Keeping-Inaction-In-Negative-Result

The-Glamour-Of-Keeping-Inaction-In-Negative-Result
https://doi.org/10.1525/collabra.74817
0 stars 0 forks source link

Peer review for The Glamour of keeping inaction in negative result #3

Open jerry-maker-765 opened 7 months ago

jerry-maker-765 commented 7 months ago

ReadMe You have done a very good job in this regard, the writing is very detailed, you labeled what is included inside each folder, a very professional presentation and very clearly stated LLM and repro. but you need a clear title, not just the title, you need to change it before submitting your final work.

Specification Your formatting is very well organized and every file is organized where it belongs. And it's labeled so clearly that you can tell what each file does in the readme.

Very pleasantly surprised to see that you have a preface for each of the code sections of the script so that the reader can know exactly what you are doing at this step.

Graph Your diagrams are made very clear and concise, every information can be easily seen and the color combination is very good, I really like the diagrams you made, they look very professional and very worthwhile for me to learn.

Main part Your introduction in the abstract and introduction section is great, I can read the general idea of this report from here and it is very engaging, you don't look like you have finished your paper yet but have a very perfect start! Looking forward to your full paper.

LLM I saw your conversation with chatgpt here and it was very well done and is very compliant.