search

JohanBendz / com.philips.hue.zigbee

Philips Hue app for Homey that uses ZigBee directly. No need for bridge.
MIT License
62 stars 45 forks source link

Wall switch module - 2nd module not working anymore #617

Open Damian-CHNL opened 1 month ago

Damian-CHNL commented 1 month ago

Dear Johan Since the recent update, the second input on the Philips Wall Switch Module isn't working anymore. Shorting the 2nd input on the physical device (with a switch) does not trigger the 2nd virtual module in your app anymore, but now wrongly triggers 1st module instead. Grateful for fixing this asap, as likely I am not the only unable to use the 2nd switch anymore. Thanks very much!

christiaandewit commented 1 month ago

You aren’t the only one indeed. However, I never managed to get the second input to work at all. Only right after adding the device to Homey (pro 2023) both inputs are working, but as soon as you add the next device (wall switch), the second input stops doing what it should. With an earlier version of the app, I encountered the same issue as you do now, but this doesn’t seem to happen with the latest release from a couple of days ago. A fix would be greatly appreciated!

christiaandewit commented 1 month ago

Small update on my experience with the Wall Switches. Apparently we got so used to the fact that the second buttons didn’t work, that we stopped using them at all. With Damian’s message in mind, I gave it a try today and, just like him, I noticed it acted like the first input was triggered when the second button is pressed. It is like that with all the Wall Switches I have that have a second input (most of them have just one input in use). Another peculiar thing I noticed is that (also since the last update) the first input doesn’t always trigger the flow. In my case, it is supposed to switch a group of lights on when they’re off or off when they’re on. This used to work fine, but now when I’ve switched the group of lights by using my phone via HomeKit, I now have to push twice to start the flow. When I only use the same switch, I only have to push once every time. It seems like somehow the current state of the lights are handled differently. @JohanBendz, hopefully this helps you find the solution!

Damian-CHNL commented 1 month ago

Hi Christiaan, Johan. Thanks for the additional comment, Christiaan. I can confirm that both buttons worked flawlessly in the app since March this year (when I installed the device and app in my Homey Pro Early 2023). But it stopped working only with the most recent update, unfortunately. Is there a way to roll back the app version within Homey Pro? Or do we have to wait for a corrective update/patch from you Johan Bendz? Any help is much appreciated. Best, Damian.

christiaandewit commented 1 month ago

@Damian-CHNL, have you been able to solve the issue or to work around it? @JohanBendz, are we doing something wrong in our settings or is this really a #bug ? Can you please find some time to look into it? I am willing to do some testing if you are unable to reproduce the issues yourself.

Damian-CHNL commented 1 month ago

Hi again. I unfortunately still have the issue too and found no workaround. I am equally willing to do some testing if needed. A fix from your side, @JohanBendz, would be still very lmuch appreciated!

sschot commented 1 week ago

I am new to the Philips Hue Module, but have the same issue. The second input is not working. Their is work in progress. So we keep calm and have patience

christiaandewit commented 5 days ago

@JohanBendz, are you still working on this project? Could you at least react to this issue to let us know if and when you will look into it? Then I can decide if it’s worth waiting even longer for a fix, or to get rid of all the Philips Hue stuff and go for a solution that actually works.

JohanBendz commented 5 days ago

Hi @christiaandewit. I was going to fix this in late October, but a construction company decided to excavate right through our fiber connection, leaving us without internet for weeks. Since we didn’t have internet, my wife decided it was a good time to renovate the office and living room. Things are now back up, and the office is mostly usable again. I just need to find the wall switch I use for testing... wherever she put it. 😂 So yes, I’m still on this. 👍

christiaandewit commented 2 days ago

OMG, @JohanBendz, how did you survive those weeks???!!! 😂 Thanks for letting us know that you haven't abandoned this project. I hope you'll soon find the switch and I hope you'll easily be able to find and fix the bug that causes these issues.

Damian-CHNL commented 2 days ago

Dear Johan. Also thanks from side side for still resolving it. Much appreciated!

Op vr, nov 22, 2024 om 13:33 schreef Christiaan de @.***>:

OMG, @JohanBendz, how did you survive those weeks???!!! 😂 Thanks for letting us know that you haven't abandoned this project. I hope you'll soon find the switch and I hope you'll easily be able to find and fix the bug that causes these issues.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>