JoinSEEDS / seeds-smart-contracts

Smart contracts for SEEDS - A Regenerative Civilization Building Game.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1C4w9Ol8VGabCIcQDVPDrwcTRoJXBqhrb7VjslwQbUGU/edit#heading=h.6f4sxygso816
MIT License
20 stars 6 forks source link

Active Citizens Quorum [Referendum #4] #437

Open n13 opened 2 years ago

n13 commented 2 years ago

B. Distinction between active & inactive Citizens for Quorum Calculation.

Implementation Team for Active Citizens Quorum: RE: → changes to SEEDS Guide Hypha: → changes to the Smart contracts

n13 commented 2 years ago

@SorinStoica4 We tried this - spent a lot of effort on it - and it failed before.

Why try this again?

It's hard to figure out who's active vs. not active.

Currently quorum is based on support levels - which was also a failure, does not work well

Meaning, it works well in some cases, and fails in other cases.

n13 commented 2 years ago

Define active Explain why this is better than all citizens Provide scenarios where it would fail.

Rieki's proposal to fix this was to change it so residents and citizens are the same, but citizens have a voter badge. So it's more clear that citizen only means "I want to participate in governance".

Right now it is presented as the "goal" for each member.

We also discussed to rename

I guess we can still have a voter badge which auto expires in 3 cycles when not voted with?

Then count number of voter badge holders?