JonasSchult / Mask3D

Mask3D predicts accurate 3D semantic instances achieving state-of-the-art on ScanNet, ScanNet200, S3DIS and STPLS3D.
MIT License
553 stars 111 forks source link

There are many small inaccuracies in the segmentation results on my dataset. Could you please provide some suggestions? #157

Open clawCa opened 8 months ago

clawCa commented 8 months ago

Thank you for open sourcing your code! I trained the model on my own dataset. In my segmentation scenario, I have a class representing over 30 potted plants. the average precision (AP) value for this class is an impressive 0.9. However, upon reviewing the segmentation results, I noticed the presence of many small instances resembling speckles on each potted plant. Could you provide some tuning advice? image

narges-tk commented 7 months ago

Thank you for open sourcing your code! I trained the model on my own dataset. In my segmentation scenario, I have a class representing over 30 potted plants. the average precision (AP) value for this class is an impressive 0.9. However, upon reviewing the segmentation results, I noticed the presence of many small instances resembling speckles on each potted plant. Could you provide some tuning advice? image

Hi! May I please ask you to share the versions of the modules that are working for you? I am getting the error especially for hydra. It seems that the reported versions in environments no longer work. Thanks in advance for your help!

clawCa commented 7 months ago

Hi! May I please ask you to share the versions of the modules that are working for you? I am getting the error especially for hydra. It seems that the reported versions in environments no longer work. Thanks in advance for your help!

hydra-core == 1.0.5, maybe you can try offline mode. environment_mask3d.zip

narges-tk commented 7 months ago

Hi! May I please ask you to share the versions of the modules that are working for you? I am getting the error especially for hydra. It seems that the reported versions in environments no longer work. Thanks in advance for your help!

hydra-core == 1.0.5, maybe you can try offline mode. environment_mask3d.zip

Many thanks for your great help!

narges-tk commented 7 months ago

Thank you for open sourcing your code! I trained the model on my own dataset. In my segmentation scenario, I have a class representing over 30 potted plants. the average precision (AP) value for this class is an impressive 0.9. However, upon reviewing the segmentation results, I noticed the presence of many small instances resembling speckles on each potted plant. Could you provide some tuning advice? image

Hi! May I please ask to guide me through how to visualize segmentation results? In fact, the following figure is the content of my visualization folder. However, when I open the .bin files of segmentation in cloud compare it is a huge file for even a very small subset and can not be opened. Thanks in advance for your help. image image

clawCa commented 7 months ago

Thank you for open sourcing your code! I trained the model on my own dataset. In my segmentation scenario, I have a class representing over 30 potted plants. the average precision (AP) value for this class is an impressive 0.9. However, upon reviewing the segmentation results, I noticed the presence of many small instances resembling speckles on each potted plant. Could you provide some tuning advice? image

Hi! May I please ask to guide me through how to visualize segmentation results? In fact, the following figure is the content of my visualization folder. However, when I open the .bin files of segmentation in cloud compare it is a huge file for even a very small subset and can not be opened. Thanks in advance for your help. image image

Based on the generated bin file names, find the code part that stores the point cloud. You need to add the code to save the point cloud and its labels. In another issue, the author replied about the methods for visualization.

narges-tk commented 7 months ago

Thank you for open sourcing your code! I trained the model on my own dataset. In my segmentation scenario, I have a class representing over 30 potted plants. the average precision (AP) value for this class is an impressive 0.9. However, upon reviewing the segmentation results, I noticed the presence of many small instances resembling speckles on each potted plant. Could you provide some tuning advice? image

Hi! May I please ask to guide me through how to visualize segmentation results? In fact, the following figure is the content of my visualization folder. However, when I open the .bin files of segmentation in cloud compare it is a huge file for even a very small subset and can not be opened. Thanks in advance for your help. image image

Based on the generated bin file names, find the code part that stores the point cloud. You need to add the code to save the point cloud and its labels. In another issue, the author replied about the methods for visualization.

Thanks a lot for your prompt help!

bh-cai commented 6 months ago

Thank you for your issues,may I know how your dataset is made, and how to use it?

bh-cai commented 6 months ago

Thank you for open sourcing your code! I trained the model on my own dataset. In my segmentation scenario, I have a class representing over 30 potted plants. the average precision (AP) value for this class is an impressive 0.9. However, upon reviewing the segmentation results, I noticed the presence of many small instances resembling speckles on each potted plant. Could you provide some tuning advice? image

Thank you for your issues,may I know how your dataset is made, and how to use it?

clawCa commented 6 months ago

Thank you for your issues,may I know how your dataset is made, and how to use it?

You need to modify the pre-processing code provided by the author based on the format of your own dataset.

Lizhinwafu commented 5 months ago

What's your training code and testing code?

BruceWayne233 commented 1 month ago

Thank you for your issues,may I know how your dataset is made, and how to use it?

You need to modify the pre-processing code provided by the author based on the format of your own dataset.

I tried to change the dataset to my own, but the predicted semantic label is always 1. And the number of points in the saved ply data is always larger than the original one. Have you ever encountered this situation? I hope to get your response in your busy schedule. Thank you.

clawCa commented 1 month ago

我尝试将数据集更改为我自己的数据集,但预测的语义标签始终为1。并且保存的层数据中的点数始终大于原始数据集。您遇到过这种情况吗?希望在您百忙之中得到您的回复。谢谢。

Yes, I've also encountered the issue of having more points than the original. My predicted semantics are all correct, it might be due to parameter settings or issues with the dataset preprocessing program.