📌 Tracking issue: comparison with equivalent other tools

[JoshuaKGoldberg]

Spinning out of #28: I want to make sure that all the nice features that other tools in the ecosystem have are considered in this repository.

👋 If you're a maintainer of any of the referenced packages then please reach out to me (I believe I've emailed you and/or pinged you in your issue tracker). I'd love to work with you on deduplicating rule implementations!

Note that this table is accurate only to my interpretation of each rule's intent - not necessarily their implementation details. For example, this package's valid-package-def might not capture every npm-package-json-lint *-type validation it's mentioned alongside. If you spot a gap in this package I'd encourage you to file a bug or feature request to fill it in.

⚠️ This is a big table and susceptible to human error. Please say something if anything is amiss!

Area emoji key:

• 🗺️: Schema validation
• 🧼: Cleanliness
• 🗜️: Version restrictions
• 📐: Sorting
• 🙅: Property restrictions
• 🧹: Whitespace formatting

Package emoji key:

• ✅: All equivalent rules have been implemented
• ✔️: All rules that would be in a recommended preset have been implemented

Area	Config	This package	eslint-plugin-json-files ✔️	eslint-plugin-node-dependencies	fixpack	npm-package-json-lint ✔️
🗺️	✔️	#48		compat-engines
🗺️	✔️	#49		valid-semver
🗺️	✔️	unique-dependencies	require-unique-dependency-names	no-dupe-deps		no-repeated-dependencies
🗺️	✔️	valid-local-dependency
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				bin-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				bundledDependencies-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				config-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				cpu-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				dependencies-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				description-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				devDependencies-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				directories-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				engines-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				files-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				homepage-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				keywords-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				license-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				main-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				man-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				name-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				no-duplicate-properties
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				optionalDependencies-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				os-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				peerDependencies-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				preferGlobal-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				private-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				repository-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				scripts-type
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				valid-values-author
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				valid-values-engines
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				valid-values-license
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				valid-values-name-scope
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				valid-values-private
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				valid-values-publishConfig
🗺️	✔️	valid-package-def				version-type
🧼		#51				prefer-scripts
🧼		#51				require-author
🧼		#51				require-bin
🧼		#51				require-bundledDependencies
🧼		#51				require-config
🧼		#51				require-contributors
🧼		#51				require-cpu
🧼		#51				require-devDependencies
🧼		#51				require-directories
🧼		#51				require-files
🧼		#51				require-funding
🧼		#51				require-main
🧼		#51				require-man
🧼		#51				require-module
🧼		#51				require-name
🧼		#51				require-optionalDependencies
🧼		#51				require-os
🧼		#51				require-peerDependencies
🧼		#51				require-preferGlobal
🧼		#51				require-private
🧼		#51				require-publishConfig
🧼		#51				require-scripts
🧼		#51				require-types
🧼		#51				require-typings
🧼		#51				require-version
🧼		#51				require-version
🧼		#51			✔️	require-bugs
🧼		#51			✔️	require-dependencies
🧼		#51			✔️	require-description
🧼		#51			✔️	require-homepage
🧼		#51			✔️	require-keywords
🧼		#51			✔️	require-repository
🧼		#51	ensure-volta-extends
🧼		#51	require-engines			require-engines
🧼		#51	require-license		✔️	require-license
🧼		#52				description-format
🧼	✔️	valid-name				name-format
🧼	✔️	valid-version				version-format
🧼	✔️	valid-repository-directory	ensure-repository-directory			require-repository-directory
🧼	✔️	order-properties				prefer-property-order
🗜️		#54				no-restricted-dependencies
🗜️		#54				no-restricted-devDependencies
🗜️		#54				no-restricted-pre-release-dependencies
🗜️		#54				no-restricted-pre-release-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	no-branch-in-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-archive-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-archive-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-caret-version-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-caret-version-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-file-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-file-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-git-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-git-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-tilde-version-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			no-tilde-version-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			prefer-no-version-zero-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges			prefer-no-version-zero-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges	absolute-version		no-absolute-version-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges	absolute-version		no-absolute-version-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges	absolute-version		prefer-absolute-version-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges	absolute-version		prefer-absolute-version-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges	prefer-caret-range-version		prefer-caret-version-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges	prefer-caret-range-version		prefer-caret-version-devDependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges	prefer-tilde-range-version		prefer-tilde-version-dependencies
🗜️		#54	restrict-ranges	prefer-tilde-range-version		prefer-tilde-version-devDependencies
📐	✔️	sort-collections				prefer-alphabetical-bundledDependencies
📐	✔️	sort-collections				prefer-alphabetical-dependencies
📐	✔️	sort-collections				prefer-alphabetical-devDependencies
📐	✔️	sort-collections				prefer-alphabetical-optionalDependencies
📐	✔️	sort-collections				prefer-alphabetical-peerDependencies
📐	✔️	sort-collections				prefer-alphabetical-scripts
🙅		#51				prefer-no-contributors
🙅		#51				prefer-no-dependencies
🙅		#51				prefer-no-devDependencies
🙅		#51				prefer-no-engineStrict
🙅		#51				prefer-no-optionalDependencies
🙅		#51				prefer-no-peerDependencies
🧹		(n/a)			✔️

I also looked at:

• https://github.com/azeemba/eslint-plugin-json#individual-rules: none seemed relevant here
• https://ota-meshi.github.io/eslint-plugin-jsonc/rules: none seemed relevant here

[JoshuaKGoldberg]

As of merging #135, I believe all the recommended-preset-level rules from eslint-plugin-json-files and npm-package-json-lint are implemented here! 🙌

That means https://github.com/JoshuaKGoldberg/create-typescript-app/issues/839 is now unblocked.

[KristjanESPERANTO]

Just an idea: I'm using normalize-package-data in one project. It is not an ESLint package, but it makes some interesting things from which one might draw inspiration :slightly_smiling_face: Or would it be possible to create rules that use this package?

[JoshuaKGoldberg]

Ooh interesting, I hadn't seen that package. Looks useful!

There might be some use in standardizing files, yeah. #85 is another example of an equivalent package being mentioned as something we may want in this repo. I'd suggest the same thing for any new tool: file an issue with the suggested new rules.

Some initial thoughts looking through its README: it looks like a lot of the rules are around standardization and data validity checking. For standardization, I think it'd be reasonable to take any where the standardized version is objectively cleaner (e.g. #71). For validity, as long as it's a clearly more-valid form (e.g. #134). But I haven't put much thought into this - definitely interested in other points of view!

[tommy-mitchell]

Another one is pkg-ok, which for example ensures that files referenced in package.json exist.

[JoshuaKGoldberg]

Ah sorry I dropped responding to pkg-ok note. It's a nice idea but the tricky thing is that a lot of packages refer to files that don't exist during development. I'm going to hold off adding that to this table - but if you want to talk about adding it in, I'd be interested in seeing a separate issue. Thanks!