JsSucks / BetterDiscordApp

Better Discord App enhances Discord desktop app with new features.
MIT License
587 stars 116 forks source link

[Feature] Detachable videos #323

Open HYPExMon5ter opened 5 years ago

HYPExMon5ter commented 5 years ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

No

Describe the solution you'd like

A button to detach a video so you can watch the youtube video/gif/any other video files your friend sent you while replying to someone else without it stopping. There were a couple plugins like this in BDV1 but they're all outdated and not working, and I feel as this should be in core BD anyways.

Describe alternatives you've considered

Additional context

Are you willing and able to implement this?

If I knew how, I would.

intrnl commented 5 years ago

This is better off done by a plugin, not by BetterDiscord itself.

HYPExMon5ter commented 5 years ago

Why's that? This feature would get used by everyone atleast once lol

zerebos commented 5 years ago

I agree wtih @intrnl. I can say with certainty that I personally wouldn't use that feature. Can you give a reason why that should be part of the core as opposed to a plugin?

HYPExMon5ter commented 5 years ago

I just feel most users would benefit from this feature 😛 but if you think this should be a plugin instead I understand, it’s just finding someone willing to make it.

snappyapple632 commented 5 years ago

Key word here: most. Most but not all users would see a benefit, and therefore it should be provided as an option as a plugin.

The same could be said about emotes, E2EE, etc but they are also optional to an extent. I can see E2EE, for example, being better as a core feature since it's about security and is more refined versus the DiscordCrypt plugin for v1.

After all, BD is about enhancing the Discord experience by letting the user choose what they want enhanced. If people want videos away from the Discord window, go ahead and make a plugin for it!

HYPExMon5ter commented 5 years ago

That’s the thing, I would make a plugin for it if I knew how. I don’t have the time to learn how currently though.