search

KRTirtho / spotube

🎧 Open source Spotify client that doesn't require Premium nor uses Electron! Available for both desktop & mobile!
https://spotube.krtirtho.dev/
Other
31.63k stars 1.31k forks source link

Play related songs after playing a searched song #461

Closed forteller closed 3 months ago

forteller commented 1 year ago

Is there an existing issue for this?

Pain

Some times I want to hear a specific song right now, so I search for it. That does not mean that I only want to hear that song, though. Still when playing a song from search it is set to repeat for forever.

Suggested solution

I prefer the way Spotify does it, where it automatically adds other, similar songs to the queue when playing a song from a search result.

Thanks for a fantastic application I use every day! :)

Useful resources

No response

Additional information

No response

RaptaG commented 1 year ago

This would require a bit of tracking tbh. Could possibly be done with local analytics

KRTirtho commented 1 year ago

This is the original task https://github.com/KRTirtho/spotube/issues/466

lpstandardrp commented 1 year ago

I have no idea if this idea is viable: what about implementing a a 'play/related tracks' function similar to those potentially found in or used by other apps (I dont know which, IIRC I found some really cool artists in Radio4000..).

I was recently looking for this function of 'automatically adding similar tracks to the queue', and found some seemingly promising apps on AlternativeTo, again IIRC, a common tag/feature of most or all of the FLOSS apps was "Music Discovery Service." I seem to recall a notably different method of finding similar tracks (as opposed to Spotify's presumably tracking involved analytics) that involved something like pulling from users with similar interests from an open-source database, or... using discogs similar tracks (or something along those lines... maybe libre.fm related, or..I'm not sure) to find similar tracks by categories, users with similar interests, I am not exactly sure... I do remember thinking 'that sounds like a clever way to prevent user-tracking while at the same time capitalizing on the benefits of pulling from extensively analyzed open data sources including other users' 'radio channels' or 'favorites playlists')... in order to find statistically.probable matches for a users interest.. I hope that makes sense, if not or for a perhaps better explanation, the wording is probably more technically savvy, concise or succinct as found on the prospective apps' alternativeto.com page.

*Note: each app has two pages/tabs: one for alternative apps (with filters for e.g. Android, Open-Source, etxc) on the '[App Name] Alternatives' page/tab, and another containing said '[App Name]'s' Information, Reviews, Links, etc. A difference between the two is, in addition or as opposed to the '[App Name] Information, Reviews,...' page/tab, the '[App Name] Alternatives' page/tab has a place beneath each Alternative App where users can mention what is different between the two respective alternative apps, pros/cons, whether the respective alternative app is a good alternative and reasons why or why not...)

Regarding the apps I fohnd that may be of relevance, the notes I took for further investigation are as follows (I hope it's okay to include this potentially long-ish list.. if not, my apologies Also, some may beore relevant than others, someay be hardly if at all relevant; I am confident most are relevant from what I recall... it should be easy to tell pretty quickly with a quick skim through both tabs, User Reviews, and Users' Pros/Cons regarding an app as alternative to the other):

Music-(LINKS) re: Online Discovery Services, Streaming, Radio, Open Decentralized Musician Promotion and Monetization Platforms, Internet Radio Service

https://alternativeto.net/software/funkwhale/about/ https://funkwhale.audio/ https://radio4000.com/ (found on alternativeto.com) https://alternativeto.net/software/blackhole-music-player/about/ (Also on Github; similar in functionality to Spotube,, maybe there is something or method they incorporate into their app that may be of use if only for ideas.) https://alternativeto.net/software/audius-music/about/ https://alternativeto.net/software/radiodroid/about/ https://github.com/segler-alex/RadioDroid https://alternativeto.net/software/openwhyd/about/ https://openwhyd.org/ https://alternativeto.net/software/navidrome/about/ https://alternativeto.net/software/tauon-music-box/about/ Tauon https://tauonmusicbox.rocks/ http://subsonic.org/ (Probably not specifically relevant, I think this is local media server)

Tags (General, each app above may have one or more of these tags/features), separated by commas: Music, Music Streaming Service, music discovery service, Open-Source, decentralized, communities, Internet Radio Service Tags, one per line (separated by 'line breaks''— I think is what the new line separators are called) : Music Music Streaming Service music discovery service subsonic music servers Open-Source decentralized communities Internet Radio Service

BloodRaven0 commented 1 year ago

+1 This feature would be huge! I know that Nuclear has this feature and it works really well. Maybe check what they're doing right and how? Another way is to somehow hijack Spotify's suggestions, but I have no idea how much their free API allows.

developer0395 commented 10 months ago

I came here search for Start Radio Feature. Yesterday I observed that its nothing but a playlist in spotify i.e. ${Song name} ${Radio}.

Thus a simple solution would be:

KRTirtho commented 3 months ago

This has been added in recent versions.

@developer0395 there's a separate issue for that.

eaui1997 commented 1 month ago

Dear @KRTirtho

Pain After i play a chill song like: On the top (Chillpeach), it play other rock, pop,... song, not play related songs

Suggested solution I think we should find other sources to start a radio from a song playing like YouTube music, ... Thanks for a fantastic application ♥️