search

Kade-github / Kade-Engine

Kade Engine is a Competitive Rhythm Game engine rewrite for FNF with Quality of Life features included.
https://kadedev.github.io/Kade-Engine/
Apache License 2.0
407 stars 603 forks source link

Enhancement: i really want the old input system back as atleast an option #179

Closed CBag23 closed 3 years ago

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

Please check for duplicates or similar issues before creating this issue.

What is your suggestion, and why should it be implemented?

i really dont like the new input system i want atleast an option to re enable the old one

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

even if the new one is on by default i just want the ability to use the old one

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

like this is a make or break for me when considering upgrading my kade engine version

CyndaquilDAC commented 3 years ago

The old one was flawed and buggy. no.

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

why remove it as an option entirely

people can use the new input system if they dont like it, and there are people who like the old input system better

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

forcing the player to use the new one kinda sucks

CyndaquilDAC commented 3 years ago

No, it doesn't. The old one misses inputs a lot. The new one literally doesn't do anything except fix the issues. If you're complaining about spamming not missing notes, then why? You can clearly see if someone is mashing.

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

i like that if you press the wrong note at the wrong time, it punishes you for it.

whats the harm in atleast keeping it as an option?

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

i dont care if other people mash, i like that i cant accidentally press the wrong note, i play a lot of rhythm games so the old input system making you miss if you press the note at the wrong time, helps me improve my accuracy

CyndaquilDAC commented 3 years ago

i like that if you press the wrong note at the wrong time, it punishes you for it.

whats the harm in atleast keeping it as an option?

Maintaining legacy stuff is a pain.

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

the thing is it was already there as an option, i wish there was atleast a way to add it back yourself or something

i think the new input system is good, i just personally prefer the old input system

CyndaquilDAC commented 3 years ago

the thing is it was already there as an option, i wish there was atleast a way to add it back yourself or something

i think the new input system is good, i just personally prefer the old input system

It wasn't actively maintained. If something broke it, it could break the game heavily and go undetected because, spoiler alert, IT ISN'T MAINTAINED.

CBag23 commented 3 years ago

Well, what about when the week 7 update drops? I'm sure it's input system is being worked on right now, so will that be implemented into a future Kade Engine version?

Kade-github commented 3 years ago

the thing is it was already there as an option, i wish there was atleast a way to add it back yourself or something i think the new input system is good, i just personally prefer the old input system

It wasn't actively maintained. If something broke it, it could break the game heavily and go undetected because, spoiler alert, IT ISN'T MAINTAINED.

^

and yes we'll be adding the old input back in week 7 if its not that bad anymore