CHI - Issues with KMT autonomy over MON, XSM, and TIB.

[ghost]

Quick questions OS: Windows 8.1 HOI4 version: 1.10.3 Kaiserreich version: Dev master 28.01.21 List any other mods used: None Were you using Steam? Yes Were you in multiplayer? No Which expansions do you NOT have? La resistance, BFTB

Explanation of the issue: After a tip from the discord, about MON_KMT cosmetic tag not appearing after MON agree's to be autonomus- and of issue with Autonomus XSM; thus I decided to quickly check those myself and see the issues with them, and I have listed them here:

• _do note, in order to test this, I quickly used console commands to get to the point of being able to offer autonomy in order to check things, and then I just use set_ruling_party on the various tags in order to get them to agree, while I personally doubt it caused any of the issues here, I am saying this to explain things like Social Conservative Ma Bufang, which appear in these screenshots)_

1. when XSM is offered Autonomy and it accepts it, 2 odd things happen- 1st is that their goverment is changed, thus leading them to become the same party as KMT, which causes them to have a Generic leader- it seems more fitting that they would keep their current goverment, just like how the other autonomies work. (see pictures 1 and 2) 2nd is that if they have MON and TIB as puppets, MON and TIB will become indepedent, which is quite odd, again as they have puppet leaders of their own. (see pictures 3 and 4)

2. When MON agrees to autonomy under KMT, they do not get the MON_KMT flag, like it seems they should. (see pictures 5 adn 6)

3. When TIB agrees to be a KMT autonomy, it does not get the TIB_KMT flag as well, instead retaining their former flag (see pictures 7 and 8)

4. This is more of a suggestion than a Bug, but I suggest that if MON agrees to be a KMT autonomy, that they switch their focus tree to the Mongolia_Puppet one, and unlock the focus MON_kuomintang (maybe this could be only done if MON is ai or something)

Steps to reproduce:

1. play CHI, take autonomus areas

2. Make an agreement for autonomy with XSM, MON and TIB, and see if these issues appear again.

Possible cause:

1. I suspect the issue here is that event chi_for.37 just has the puppet effect on XSM, rather than having the the get_current_government_type and restore_previous_government_type effects, as well as not having them transfer their puppets to CHI, thus causing them to become free.

           CHI = {
               puppet = XSM
           }

   2. the issue here simply seems to be that event chi_for.52 does not give MON the MON_KMT cosmetic tag, leading them to staying as normal mongolia.

3. As it seems that TIB is handled by the same event chi_for.52, there needs to be a check so TIB will get the TIB_KMT cosmetic tag if it agrees to become CHI puppet in that event.

Screenshots:

• Picture 1: XSM before agreeing to autonomy (as you can see I just set their ruling party to SocCon so they would agree, but I don't think it has in reason to affect the findings)

• Picture 2: XSM after becoming puppet- as you can see it now has a generic leader- which is odd seeing as they agreed on the basis that they get to keep their own goverment

• Picture 3: After XSM became a puppet, their puppet MON became independent-

• Picture 4: Same happend with TIB (which is even weirder in this case seeing as Ma biao is a XSM general)

• Picture 5: after reloading a save, here is MON before agreeing to Autonomy- (I changed their ruling party to social democrat so they will agree, but again doubt it caused the issue)

• Picture 6: MON after agreeing to autonomy and becoming CHI's puppet- as you can see they keep their old flag and don't get MON_KMT cosmetic tag

• Picture 7: TIB before agreeing to autonomy

• Picture 8: TIB after agreeing to autonomy- as you can see they did not get the TIB_KMT cosmetic tag

[ghost]

I didn't code these aspects so I am unaware of how they function, that said once I am no longer busy I will have a look into these issues.

[emwe39]

did some research on this, looks like while the MON_KMT and TIB_KMT cosmetics are defined, there is no code anywhere that would actually set those cosmetics for the tags.

enemy puppets not being part of the peace conference if you haven't touched their land is vanilla behaviour, btw.

[ghost]

enemy puppets not being part of the peace conference if you haven't touched their land is vanilla behaviour, btw.

there was no peace confrence in this case- as said XSM became a puppet by event- event chi_for.37 in this case, but released their Mongol and TIB puppets, instead of transfering them to CHI- since XSM will almost always have TIB and MON as puppets if they survive up to this point, this seems like its a significant issue

[emwe39]

partially fixed, Tibet and Mongolia get their KMT cosmetic tags now

[Alpinia]

Fixed.