search

Kaiserreich / Kaiserreich-4-Bug-Reports

Issue tracker for Kaiserreich for Hearts of Iron 4
110 stars 40 forks source link

MAF - German Government in Exile not collapsing after -40% stability. #17374

Closed TheRealVladimirLemon closed 2 years ago

TheRealVladimirLemon commented 3 years ago

Quick questions OS: HOI4 version: 1.10.8 Kaiserreich version: 0.19 List any other mods used: None Were you using Steam? Yes Were you in multiplayer? No Which expansions do you NOT have? None

Explanation of the issue: The German Government in Exile reached -40% stability with the national spirit 'on borrowed time' but did not collapse, even reaching -44% with nothing happening.

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Have Mittleafrika release Uganda, Rwanda, Burundi, and Zambia as puppets.

  2. Have the Third Internationale at war with the German Government in Exile.

  3. Ensure that the German Government in Exile has the 'on borrowed time' spirit.

  4. Use spies to help decrease stability with the propaganda mission to below -40%.

Possible cause: The war between the TI and the GGiE. Mittleafrika releaseing four African nations as puppets. Using spies to lower the stability instead of letting it collapse naturally.

Screenshots: Screen Shot 2021-09-10 at 10 59 06 PM

Alpinia commented 3 years ago

Was the MAF collapse disabled via game rules, or does GEX control any territory in Europe?

TheRealVladimirLemon commented 3 years ago

Was the MAF collapse disabled via game rules, or does GEX control any territory in Europe?

No, MAF collapse was not disabled, and the GEX (didn't realize it had a different tag than Mittleafrika) held no territory in Europe. It was renegaded to mostly central Africa, with the TI controlling most of the North West and Angola of Mittleafrika.

Alpinia commented 3 years ago

There is a certain delay to it - the collapse can happen at any point after MAF/GEX reaches -40% stability. I'm fairly sure this is just the event's natural delay, but if you could send a save for us to be certain, that would be ideal.

Alpinia commented 2 years ago

With no further info incoming, I'll assume that this was just caused by the event's natural delay.

TheRealVladimirLemon commented 2 years ago

Sorry I took so long to respond, I was busy and it slipped my mind. I’m not sure what the natural delay is, but it reached -43% stability at one point, not sure if I have a save game with the GGE still alive, because of iron man, but I have one just in general. However, I waited many weeks afterwards, and no event triggered. The same issue happened in another game afterwards in which MAF didn’t collapse after reaching -40% while in its bush war with Portugal. Both times the modifier didn’t fire when they were at war. But my most recent game played Mittleafrika collapsed but they weren’t at war.

Alpinia commented 2 years ago

Could you provide a save of the issue? Also, do note that MAF cannot collapse during the Bush War.