search

KantaraInitiative / SAMLprofiles

SAML interoperability and deployment profiles
Other
11 stars 4 forks source link

(Response to Feedback Item 18) Add non-normative mention of shibmd:scope in SDP-SP20 #95

Closed judielaine closed 5 years ago

judielaine commented 6 years ago

If shibmd:scope is included, it is likely only relevant in our R&E context. Can’t put a shibboleth-specific thing into the doc as normative, but could certainly mention it Genesis of the issue where shibmd:scope had been normatively defined as case-sensitive, and software was not honoring that Scott will clean up the shibboleth wiki doc on this topic to remove ‘under development’ and get the non-normative text added here that references the shibboleth docs. Can say things like ‘domain-like syntax, authorizing specific domains, metadata used for authorizing these domains’ Will reference OASIS identifiers spec

scantor commented 6 years ago

OASIS has indicated we can propose standardization of this extension without renaming it, so the plan is to do so in the subject-id draft and then update the language here to reflect that. Unclear at this point to what degree it would be normative since this is really about policy. We should at least reference it certainly.

scantor commented 6 years ago

A new OASIS draft was pre-circulated to our group today for comment. Once that's done, we'll tackle revising the material in here.

scantor commented 6 years ago

Noting I submitted a working draft to OASIS with the additional work. Next step is the text on this side.

scantor commented 5 years ago

This never got closed.