KantaraInitiative / SAMLprofiles

SAML interoperability and deployment profiles
Other
11 stars 4 forks source link

(Response to Feedback Item 19) Intentionally supported features (Merge MD05 in to MD04) #98

Closed judielaine closed 6 years ago

judielaine commented 6 years ago

Addressing Feedback Item 19 “deliberate and intentional configuration” is the confusion point here, need to clarify that to: don’t put in config info for profiles/services you’re not supporting. “Don’t put stuff in the metadata that you don’t support/understand/need. What is needed is included. Don’t put stuff in the metadata that is going to break things.” Make the ‘MUST NOT’ a ‘SHOULD NOT’. But then is this not a requirement? Then maybe it should move up into MD-04. Should it stay? The main clue needs to be there because people always make the mistake of ‘if it’s omitted, it’s prohibited’. Could stuff this right between the two existing paragraphs in MD-04. Merge MD05 in to MD04 (between existing paragraphs) and remove the text “or that have not been deliberately and intentionally configured” from the MD05 text Scott AI to do this