Open KhoonSun47 opened 4 months ago
Thanks for spotting the issue. Indeed the app does not have such status bar but the DG does not reflect so.
Team chose [severity.VeryLow
]
Originally [severity.Low
]
Reason for disagreement: I disagree with the decision to downgrade the severity of this response from "Low" to "VeryLow."
This issue is not merely cosmetic; it impacts usability.
The application's "Instructions for Manual Testing" refer to the "status bar," yet neither the User Guide (UG) nor Developer Guide (DG) explains what the "status bar" is.
Additionally, your team's response acknowledges that the application does not feature a status bar; however, the inclusion of this term in "Instruction for Manual Testing" could mislead users to attempt to locate the status bar while testing the application.

Steps to reproduce:
When following the "deleting a person" feature under "Instructions for Manual Testing", after running the delete command, it is stated that the "Timestamp in the status bar is edited" - which users may assumed that there is a status bar that shows the "Timestamp".![image.png](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/KhoonSun47/pe/main/files/3664c856-51a5-4747-9029-09f274d5b3f1.png)
However, in both the UG and DG, it is not stated that what the status bar is. It only described what are Overview Side Panel, Person List and Role List is.![image.png](https://raw.githubusercontent.com/KhoonSun47/pe/main/files/98b4404a-4053-4aa2-b84a-2e98d55989c3.png)
Suggestion: I believe that UG should clearly states what the different part of the UI means in the application (in a list manner), which is less confusing for the user.