levelConfig save button missing with multiple Endpoints

[Nailik]

What happened?

Using modernExtend with a setup like:

deviceEndpoints({endpoints: {'left': 4, 'right': 3}}),
light({endpointNames: ['left', 'right'], configureReporting: true, levelConfig: {}}),

When changing the levelConfig (onLevel) in the UI i see Received MQTT message on 'zigbee2mqtt/licht_wohnzimmer/set' with data '{"level_config_right":{"on_level_right":116}}' After requesting update from device: '{"ballast_lamp_alarm_lamp_burn_hours":false,"ballast_maximum_level":50,"ballast_maximum_level_right":254,"ballast_minimum_level":1,"ballast_minimum_level_right":1,"ballast_status_lamp_failure":false,"ballast_status_non_operational":false,"brightness":254,"brightness_left":150,"brightness_right":100,"dimmer_mode":"auto","indicator_mode_left_btn":"always_on","indicator_mode_right_btn":"always_off","level_config":{"current_level_startup":"minimum","execute_if_off":false,"on_level":150},"linkquality":188,"power_on_behavior":null,"state":"ON","state_left":"ON","state_right":"ON","switch_actions_left_btn":"dimmer_opposite","switch_actions_right_btn":"dimmer_opposite"}'

You can see that the on_level did not change correctly but it works by using dev console (endpoint 3 or 4, .LevelCtrl cluster and onLevel attribute) there also read and write works.

What did you expect to happen?

Correctly update onLevel depending on correct endpoint.

How to reproduce it (minimal and precise)

No response

Zigbee2MQTT version

1.36.1

Adapter firmware version

7.2.2.0 build 190

Adapter

EZSP v11

Setup

HomeAssistant

Debug log

No response

[mrskycriper]

This should be fixed in https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee-herdsman-converters/pull/7374

Can you test it on a dev version?

[Nailik]

I tried on this commit https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/commit/e10ab5c

And it doesn't work. What also looks weird in the logs is that there is only one level_config field but there should be 2 (left and right dimmer)

[2024-04-12 17:52:03] debug:    z2m: MQTT publish: topic 'zigbee2mqtt/licht_wohnzimmer', payload '{"ballast_lamp_alarm_lamp_burn_hours":false,"ballast_maximum_level":50,"ballast_maximum_level_right":254,"ballast_minimum_level":1,"ballast_minimum_level_right":1,"ballast_status_lamp_failure":false,"ballast_status_non_operational":false,"brightness":254,"brightness_left":254,"brightness_right":254,"dimmer_mode":"auto","indicator_mode_left_btn":"always_on","indicator_mode_right_btn":"always_off","level_config":{"current_level_startup":"minimum","execute_if_off":false,"on_level":4},"linkquality":216,"power_on_behavior":null,"state":"ON","state_left":"OFF","state_right":"ON","switch_actions_left_btn":"dimmer_opposite","switch_actions_right_btn":"dimmer_opposite"}'
[2024-04-12 17:52:03] debug:    z2m: MQTT publish: topic 'zigbee2mqtt/licht_wohnzimmer/left', payload '{"brightness":254,"indicator_mode":"always_on","state":"OFF","switch_actions":"dimmer_opposite"}'
[2024-04-12 17:52:03] debug:    z2m: MQTT publish: topic 'zigbee2mqtt/licht_wohnzimmer/right', payload '{"ballast_maximum_level":254,"ballast_minimum_level":1,"brightness":254,"indicator_mode":"always_off","state":"ON","switch_actions":"dimmer_opposite"}'

[Nailik]

Btw device definition:

zigbeeModel: ['2GANG/DIMMER/2'],
    model: 'MEG5126-0300/MEG5172-0000',
    vendor: 'Schneider Electric',
    description: 'Merten MEG5172 PlusLink Dimmer insert with Merten Wiser System M Push Button (2fold)',
    fromZigbee: [fz.wiser_lighting_ballast_configuration],
    toZigbee: [tz.ballast_config, tz.wiser_dimmer_mode],
    exposes: [
        e.numeric('ballast_minimum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the minimum light output of the ballast'),
        e.numeric('ballast_maximum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the maximum light output of the ballast'),
        e.enum('dimmer_mode', ea.ALL, ['auto', 'rc', 'rl', 'rl_led'])
            .withDescription('Sets dimming mode to autodetect or fixed RC/RL/RL_LED mode (max load is reduced in RL_LED)'),
    ],
    extend: [
        deviceEndpoints({endpoints: {'left': 4, 'right': 3, 'left_btn': 22, 'right_btn': 21}}),
        light({endpointNames: ['left', 'right'], configureReporting: true, levelConfig: {}}),
        switchActions('left_btn'), switchActions('right_btn'), indicatorMode('left_btn'),
    ],

[mrskycriper]

And it doesn't work

What part isn't working? Only one level config? Both? Dimming too? I'm a bit confused here

[Nailik]

Only the levelConfig i want to change "onLevel" attribute withing "LevelControl" It works in Dev console but it doesn't have an effect in ui

[Nailik]

I did just notice that when i use old extend there is a save button next to the LevelConfig and then it works, could this be the issue?

[Nailik]

@Koenkk could you maybe have a look why the save changes button is missing?

[Nailik]

I think the issue is not ModernExtend but the Save button when using mutliple endpoints.

One endpoint with legacy extend, button is visible:

const definition = {
    zigbeeModel: ['2GANG/DIMMER/2'],
    model: 'MEG5126-0300/MEG5172-0000',
    vendor: 'Schneider Electric',
    description: 'Merten MEG5172 PlusLink Dimmer insert with Merten Wiser System M Push Button (2fold)',
    fromZigbee: [fz.wiser_lighting_ballast_configuration, fz.level_config],
    toZigbee: [tz.ballast_config, tz.wiser_dimmer_mode, tz.level_config],
    exposes: [
        e.light_brightness().withLevelConfig().withEndpoint(),
        e.numeric('ballast_minimum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the minimum light output of the ballast'),
        e.numeric('ballast_maximum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the maximum light output of the ballast'),
        e.enum('dimmer_mode', ea.ALL, ['auto', 'rc', 'rl', 'rl_led'])
            .withDescription('Sets dimming mode to autodetect or fixed RC/RL/RL_LED mode (max load is reduced in RL_LED)'),
    ],
    extend: [
        deviceEndpoints({endpoints: {'left': 4, 'right': 3, 'left_btn': 22, 'right_btn': 21}}),
        light({endpointNames: ['left', 'right'], configureReporting: true}),
        switchActions('left_btn'), switchActions('right_btn'), indicatorMode('left_btn'),
    ],
};

Multiple endpoint (with legacy extend using .withEndpoint), save button is missing

const definition = {
    zigbeeModel: ['2GANG/DIMMER/2'],
    model: 'MEG5126-0300/MEG5172-0000',
    vendor: 'Schneider Electric',
    description: 'Merten MEG5172 PlusLink Dimmer insert with Merten Wiser System M Push Button (2fold)',
    fromZigbee: [fz.wiser_lighting_ballast_configuration, fz.level_config],
    toZigbee: [tz.ballast_config, tz.wiser_dimmer_mode, tz.level_config],
    exposes: [
        e.light_brightness().withLevelConfig().withEndpoint('left'),
        e.numeric('ballast_minimum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the minimum light output of the ballast'),
        e.numeric('ballast_maximum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the maximum light output of the ballast'),
        e.enum('dimmer_mode', ea.ALL, ['auto', 'rc', 'rl', 'rl_led'])
            .withDescription('Sets dimming mode to autodetect or fixed RC/RL/RL_LED mode (max load is reduced in RL_LED)'),
    ],
    extend: [
        deviceEndpoints({endpoints: {'left': 4, 'right': 3, 'left_btn': 22, 'right_btn': 21}}),
        light({endpointNames: ['left', 'right'], configureReporting: true}),
        switchActions('left_btn'), switchActions('right_btn'), indicatorMode('left_btn'),
    ],
};

Multiple endpoint with modern extend (save button is missing)

const definition = {
    zigbeeModel: ['2GANG/DIMMER/2'],
    model: 'MEG5126-0300/MEG5172-0000',
    vendor: 'Schneider Electric',
    description: 'Merten MEG5172 PlusLink Dimmer insert with Merten Wiser System M Push Button (2fold)',
    fromZigbee: [fz.wiser_lighting_ballast_configuration, fz.level_config],
    toZigbee: [tz.ballast_config, tz.wiser_dimmer_mode, tz.level_config],
    exposes: [
        e.numeric('ballast_minimum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the minimum light output of the ballast'),
        e.numeric('ballast_maximum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the maximum light output of the ballast'),
        e.enum('dimmer_mode', ea.ALL, ['auto', 'rc', 'rl', 'rl_led'])
            .withDescription('Sets dimming mode to autodetect or fixed RC/RL/RL_LED mode (max load is reduced in RL_LED)'),
    ],
    extend: [
        deviceEndpoints({endpoints: {'left': 4, 'right': 3, 'left_btn': 22, 'right_btn': 21}}),
        light({endpointNames: ['left'], configureReporting: true, levelConfig: {}}),
        switchActions('left_btn'), switchActions('right_btn'), indicatorMode('left_btn'),
    ],
};

[Koenkk]

One endpoint with legacy extend, button is visible:

Is one endpoint + modern extend working?

[Nailik]

no it seems like the indentation of level config might be the issue

one endpoint (remove other stuff)

const definition = {
    zigbeeModel: ['2GANG/DIMMER/2'],
    model: 'MEG5126-0300/MEG5172-0000',
    vendor: 'Schneider Electric',
    description: 'Merten MEG5172 PlusLink Dimmer insert with Merten Wiser System M Push Button (2fold)',
    fromZigbee: [fz.wiser_lighting_ballast_configuration, fz.level_config],
    toZigbee: [tz.ballast_config, tz.wiser_dimmer_mode, tz.level_config],
    exposes: [
        e.numeric('ballast_minimum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the minimum light output of the ballast'),
        e.numeric('ballast_maximum_level', ea.ALL).withValueMin(1).withValueMax(254)
            .withDescription('Specifies the maximum light output of the ballast'),
        e.enum('dimmer_mode', ea.ALL, ['auto', 'rc', 'rl', 'rl_led'])
            .withDescription('Sets dimming mode to autodetect or fixed RC/RL/RL_LED mode (max load is reduced in RL_LED)'),
    ],
    extend: [
        deviceEndpoints({endpoints: {'left': 4}}),
        light({endpointNames: ['left'], configureReporting: true, levelConfig: {}}),
    ],
};

[github-actions[bot]]

This issue is stale because it has been open 180 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 30 days