Invalide state tuya shutter since v1.39.00

[ElCaplar]

Hello everyone,

Following an update to Zigbee2MQTT 1.39.00 , I have noticed strange behavior with some of my roller shutters (specifically those with modules recognized as TUYA-TS130F. I have 2 other MOES modules [MS-108ZR] that are working correctly).

When I fully raise the shutter, the status visible in Home Assistant is "closed" even though the shutter is open. Below is the trace from the development menu:

state : closed
current_position: 100
backlight_mode: null
calibration: "OFF"
calibration_time: 32
indicator_mode: "off"
linkquality: 255
motor_reversal: "OFF"
moving: STOP
position: 100
friendly_name: volet-salon
supported_features: 15

On zigbeemqtt interface here is :

{ "calibration": "OFF", "calibration_time": 32, "indicator_mode": "off", "linkquality": 255, "motor_reversal": "OFF", "moving": "STOP", "position": 100, "state": "OPEN" }

The shutter appears closed while it is actually open. When I click on "STOP," the status updates correctly

I am experiencing exactly the same strange behavior when I close the shutter, as it appears to be in open mode. When I use intermediate positions, there is no issue.

When i downgrade on 1.38.00 version, all is ok.

Do you have any possible solutions or workarounds for this behavior?

Originally posted by @ElCaplar in https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/discussions/23480

[matwojcik]

Similar issue was described here: https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/issues/23277 but there they mention HA as a buggy, once you say that downgrade of Z2M helps.

[platte-73]

I have the same problem after update z2m

[eerguen]

I have the same problem with two Moes TS130F (_TZ3000_1dd0d5yi) devices. Shutters are open - HA shows closed and vice versa. Connection correct - hardware buttons work. Two are partially not working and two without any issues. Sometimes I have to press the switch three times for the shutter to close / open completely. It behaves very strangely and is annoying.

{ "calibration": "ON", "calibration_time": 19, "linkquality": 69, "motor_reversal": "OFF", "moving": "STOP", "position": 0, "state": "CLOSE", "update": { "installed_version": 71, "latest_version": 71, "state": "idle" } }

[Koenkk]

Are they open or closed with "position": 0, "state": "CLOSE"?

[eerguen]

Are they open or closed with "position": 0, "state": "CLOSE"?

In this state, the roller shutter is completely open. In the “open” state, the roller shutter is closed. However, the switches function correctly.

[Koenkk]

@eerguen fixed!

Changes will be available in the dev branch in a few hours from now.

[Suschibomber]

Hey... After the newest update my cover status is shown incorrectly :( before the update my moes roller shutters works perfectly fine. HA is showning closing but in truth it is opening in this moment. Motor Revese does not change it.

[crazyserver]

Same happen to me, after I updated today's version.

Model zb TS130F Manufacturer zb _TZ3000_1dd0d5yi Manufacturer Moes Model MS-108ZR

[rogervdh]

I have the same issue after updating to Z2M 1.41.0. It was always working perfectly with the Moes MS-108ZR and Z2M 1.40.2 (and all earlier versions) and since the update to 1.41.0 the cover status is incorrect. I seems that only the MS-108ZR shutter switches are affected. Other TS130F shutter switches in my setup are still working correctly (also after the update to 1.41.0).

[aqwserf]

Well, same issue on my side with 4 MS-108ZR. Back to normal when reverting back to 1.40.2-1

[afharo]

Same here for _TZ3000_1dd0d5yi. They used to work as expected.

After the update, I had to enable the invert mode for them work as expected again. However, now my physical controls are inverted and I will need to rewire 😞.

[afharo]

Other TS130F shutter switches in my setup are still working correctly (also after the update to 1.41.0).

@rogervdh, can you share the "Zigbee manufacturer" for the shutters that don't work and the ones that work?

I have the suspicion that _TZ3000_1dd0d5yi are broken with the update but others might be ok.

[rogervdh]

Other TS130F shutter switches in my setup are still working correctly (also after the update to 1.41.0).

@rogervdh, can you share the "Zigbee manufacturer" for the shutters that don't work and the ones that work?

I have the suspicion that _TZ3000_1dd0d5yi are broken with the update but others might be ok.

@afharo, TS130F Moes switch which doesn't work correctly since 1.41.0:

Zigbee Model TS130F Zigbee Manufacturer _TZ3000_1dd0d5yi Description Zigbee + RF curtain switch module

Other TS130F switches which are still working correctly:

Zigbee Model TS130F Zigbee Manufacturer _TZ3000_ltiqubue Description Curtain/blind switch

Zigbee Model TS130F Zigbee Manufacturer _TZ3000_qqdbccb3 Description Curtain/blind switch

[Koenkk]

Can you provide the data/database.db entry of _TZ3000_1dd0d5yi and indicated wether the state is inverted with 1.41.0 or not?

[aqwserf]

@Koenkk FWIW, with my _TZ3000_1dd0d5yi fully open on 1.41.0:

$ cat database.db | jq 'select(.ieeeAddr == "0x540f57fffe896eab")'
{
  "id": 28,
  "type": "Router",
  "ieeeAddr": "0x540f57fffe896eab",
  "nwkAddr": 29337,
  "manufId": 4098,
  "manufName": "_TZ3000_1dd0d5yi",
  "powerSource": "Mains (single phase)",
  "modelId": "TS130F",
  "epList": [
    1
  ],
  "endpoints": {
    "1": {
      "profId": 260,
      "epId": 1,
      "devId": 515,
      "inClusterList": [
        0,
        4,
        5,
        258,
        6
      ],
      "outClusterList": [
        25,
        10
      ],
      "clusters": {
        "genBasic": {
          "attributes": {
            "65503": "�\u0010�.\u0016",
            "65506": 31,
            "65508": 0,
            "modelId": "TS130F",
            "manufacturerName": "_TZ3000_1dd0d5yi",
            "powerSource": 1,
            "zclVersion": 3,
            "appVersion": 71,
            "stackVersion": 0,
            "hwVersion": 1,
            "dateCode": ""
          }
        },
        "closuresWindowCovering": {
          "attributes": {
            "moesCalibrationTime": 280,
            "tuyaMovingState": 1,
            "currentPositionLiftPercentage": 100,
            "tuyaMotorReversal": 0,
            "tuyaCalibration": 0
          }
        },
        "genOnOff": {
          "attributes": {
            "20480": 0,
            "tuyaBacklightSwitch": 0
          }
        }
      },
      "binds": [],
      "configuredReportings": [],
      "meta": {}
    }
  },
  "appVersion": 71,
  "stackVersion": 0,
  "hwVersion": 1,
  "dateCode": "",
  "zclVersion": 3,
  "interviewCompleted": true,
  "meta": {},
  "lastSeen": 1730708760400
}

$ cat state.json | jq '."0x540f57fffe896eab"'
{
  "calibration_time": 28,
  "moving": "STOP",
  "position": 100,
  "motor_reversal": "OFF",
  "linkquality": 255,
  "state": "OPEN",
  "update": {
    "state": "idle",
    "installed_version": 71,
    "latest_version": 71
  },
  "update_available": false,
  "calibration": "ON"
}
$

Reverting back to 1.40.2-1 (without moving the cover manually or through HA). Shown as open in HA:

$ cat database.db | jq 'select(.ieeeAddr == "0x540f57fffe896eab")' | diff - 1410_db_open
73c73
<   "lastSeen": 1730709188731
---
>   "lastSeen": 1730708760400

$ cat state.json | jq '."0x540f57fffe896eab"' | diff - 1410_state_open 
4c4
<   "position": 0,
---
>   "position": 100,
7c7
<   "state": "CLOSE",
---
>   "state": "OPEN",

After pressing open in Z2MQTT (did nothing as the cover was already opened):

$ cat state.json | jq '."0x540f57fffe896eab"' | diff - 1410_state_open
$

[Murada99]

Same for me, after the update: When it's closed, I get the following states: { "calibration": "ON", "calibration_time": 47, "last_seen": "2024-11-04T16:13:41.251Z", "linkquality": 43, "motor_reversal": "OFF", "moving": "STOP", "position": 100, "state": "OPEN" } I had to enable the invert mode for them work as expected again but I need to change all my automations.

[0rni1]

Hello, I’m also having the same issue with the 1.41.0-1 update. The cover’s state appears inverted; when it’s closed, it shows as open. The open and close buttons work correctly. I have the Moes MS-108ZR model. I have returned to the previous version of zigbee 2 Mqtt and everything is correct.

[Murada99]

Seems to be the same issue as this one #23277

[devilvan33]

Hello, in the latest version 1.41 the MOES MS-108ZR device does not work correctly. When it is closed it appears open and vice versa. I have gone back to the previous version and it works fine again.

[Koenkk]

I think it was fixed in https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/issues/23483 already, can you check if everything is ok with the dev branch?

[afharo]

I guess you meant #24609, updating the converters with this changelog: https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee-herdsman-converters/pull/8259 🧡

[theyort]

The malfunction is still present. When the shutter finishes opening, it appears as closed, and conversely, when the shutter closes, it then appears as open. I reverted to version 1.39.1 to restore normal functionality. Moes MS-108ZR

[Koenkk]

@theyort did you also check thedev branch?

[afharo]

I think it was fixed in #23483 already, can you check if everything is ok with the dev branch?

I just tested the docker tag latest-dev and it works for me as intended. I only own _TZ3000_1dd0d5yi, though. So maybe owners of the other models can confirm that it still works for them in those ones.