Closed hmorkemo closed 2 years ago
I have 3 philips lights: bakgården1, 2 and 3, and a zigbee group "bakgården".
They are quite close to each other.
Lights 1 and 3 are controllable like they should be.
Light 2, located in the middle, is not. When I switch it on/off there's no reaction except for the message:
Publish 'set' 'state' to 'Bakgården2' failed: 'Error: Command 0x0017880102b354a7/11 genOnOff.on({}, {"sendWhenActive":false,"timeout":10000,"disableResponse":false,"disableRecovery":false,"disableDefaultResponse":false,"direction":0,"srcEndpoint":null,"reservedBits":0,"manufacturerCode":null,"transactionSequenceNumber":null,"writeUndiv":false}) failed (no response received)'
BUT: When I switch on/off/dim using the group, all 3 lights behave just fine! And no error messages.
This seems, to me, very strange. Bug in zigbee2mqtt? or in ConBee II?
I noticed the same issue, also using a Conbee II. My network is quite big with 73 devices, but is should be enough for the conbee to handle. it happends most often when I send commands to a loth of lights at the same time (lets say at the evening i turn on 10 lights at the same time).
Hello,
I have the same problem. my whole hue system is unstable since version 1.21.2. I am losing the connection of certain bulbs. I have to restart Z2M, it works again for a few minutes and then I lose the connection to the bulbs again.
Several posts were opened without response.
https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/discussions/9101 https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/issues/8815 https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/issues/9188 https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/issues/8830 https://github.com/Koenkk/zigbee2mqtt/issues/8993
Same here. Today I upgraded my system + reboot. Again 2 IKEA light bulbs were unresponsive. What helps for me than is
So it seems the bulb was still member of my zigbee mesh, but just has forgotten that...
Grtz B
Same here, using a Conbee 2.
Have not had this issue until last weekend, when I updated both stick firmware to 26720700 and z2Mqtt to latest.
After those updates the problems started.
It only happens to Hue lights (even very old Bloom), OSRAM Lights are working fine. Xiaomi devices are fine.
The Hue lights are responsive for ~30 seconds after power cycle, after that I do receive only timeouts...
Could anyone try to downgrade conbee2 an check? I do not have an environment available for flashing the stick right now...
Downgraded to
Zigbee2MQTT Version 1.21.0 commit: 70891eec Coordinator Typ ConBee2/RaspBee2 Coordinator Version 0x26680700 Frontend Version 0.5.18
Problems still occur.
Another Observation:
I do have on Hue e14 Bulb with firmware 1.46.13_r26312. It does not lose connection. Is very responsive. Firmware Update is available but fails.
I also had an old Hue Iris which was responsive until I updated the bulb firmware to 5.127.1.26581. Since then Iris not answering anymore. All other hue bulbs have firmware 5.127.1.26581 as well.
So the root cause might rather be the Hue bulb Firmware or a combination of bulb firmware and z2mqqt
For me the issue is that random devices do not respond, it looks like it's happening when i send out multiple commands at the same time, for example if i set that 4 lights should go on, only 3 respond the other give a timeout error.
Did another check. Connected the updated Hue Iris to a HUE Bridge. Bulb stays responsive all the time. Checked for further bulb firmware updates with HUE Bridge - nothing available
@funkstille could you provide a sniff of this happening? https://www.zigbee2mqtt.io/advanced/zigbee/04_sniff_zigbee_traffic.html#with-cc2531 Please also share your network key so that I can decrypt the sniff.
@Koenkk Will try later that evening. Never tried before. To get it right: Do I need the flashed cc2531 additional to the CONBEE2 stick?
@funkstille yes, conbee 2 as your coordinator, cc2531 for the sniffing.
Since this is the first time I've done this, I don't know what to look for. I have noticed these errors:
Frame 337: 57 bytes on wire (456 bits), 57 bytes captured (456 bits) on interface -, id 0
Interface id: 0 (-)
Encapsulation type: IEEE 802.15.4 Wireless PAN (104)
Arrival Time: Dec 6, 2021 13:31:49.323930000 CET
[Time shift for this packet: 0.000000000 seconds]
Epoch Time: 1638793909.323930000 seconds
[Time delta from previous captured frame: 0.721275000 seconds]
[Time delta from previous displayed frame: 0.721275000 seconds]
[Time since reference or first frame: 140.323930000 seconds]
Frame Number: 337
Frame Length: 57 bytes (456 bits)
Capture Length: 57 bytes (456 bits)
[Frame is marked: False]
[Frame is ignored: False]
[Protocols in frame: wpan:data]
IEEE 802.15.4 Data, Dst: 0xffcf, Src: 0x65c1, Bad FCS
Frame Control Field: 0x8841, Frame Type: Data, PAN ID Compression, Destination Addressing Mode: Short/16-bit, Frame Version: IEEE Std 802.15.4-2003, Source Addressing Mode: Short/16-bit
Sequence Number: 200
Destination PAN: 0x1a62
Destination: 0xffcf
Source: 0x65c1
FCS: 0x0000 (Incorrect, expected FCS=0x4678)
[Expert Info (Warning/Checksum): Bad FCS]
[Bad FCS]
[Severity level: Warning]
[Group: Checksum]
Data (46 bytes)
Data: 0802fcffc1651ed828e1f0050655f2e7000123170000c021eac0aa2b72ffb901af66289c…
[Length: 46]
Maybe these errors cause the device to be blocked?
@funkstille most of the time this is due to your sniffer being too far away from the transmitting devices, therefore usually not a problem.
Ok. I will try again an move the bulb closer to the sniffer ;)
If I move the bulb closer to the stay reactive, I was even able to do a firmware update. But If I move the bulb to its origin place (with power off / on) it gets recognized but has the same problem as before: not responsive after a few seconds. I have a lot of sniffing logs. But I could not find any evidence since I am no expert.
There are enough routers (innr plugs, osram lights) in the house. It has worked for months without any problem. Only the Hue bulbs with newer firmware "get lost". 1 hue with an old firmware stays responsive even though it has hardly no connection (LQI < 50). Attached is a Wireshark file where 0x5c3b becomes unresponsive after I moved it to its origin place.
@chrishae do you know if this is a known problem with the conbee II?
Not really. We have also networks running with > 100 devices. I can just recomend to update the FW to the latest version 26720700 and to try to use an USB extension cable with the ConBee2. Also there is a new FW available for IKEA devices that address the describted issues: https://www.reddit.com/r/tradfri/comments/rg77ed/new_firmware_release/
Today I flashed deCONZ firmware version 26680700
sudo GCFFlasher_internal -t 60 -d /dev/ttyACM0 -f deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x264a0700.bin.GCF
GCFFlasher V3_17 (c) dresden elektronik ingenieurtechnik gmbh
Reboot device /dev/serial/by-id/usb-dresden_elektronik_ingenieurtechnik_GmbH_ConBee_II_DE2214230-if00 (ConBee II)
deCONZ firmware version 26680700
and restarted zigbee2mqtt - everything is up and running again with latest zigbee2mqtt version. No problems with unresponsive hue bulbs anymore. I will test for a few days and try to update to latest conbee 2 firmware to double check if the problem occours again.
I had similar issues with the latest firmware for the conbee II mostly with some hue bulbs and ikea TRADFRI drivers. Also for me, unitl now, the downgrade to 26680700 firmware improved the availability of the devices.
@funkstille Did you try to update again to a newer fw in the meantime?
@olschm No, I did not try to upgrade so far. I haven’t had a single issue with unresponsive bulbs since downgrading.
Since all other devices also working without problems there is no need to upgrade for me so far.
I been experiencing the same problem for a while. Some Hue bulbs became unresponsive after a couple of seconds, while similar bulbs, next to the other one, would continue to work fine.
After reading @funkstille most recent posts I gave it another try and tested with firmware 26720700 and 26680700 of the ConBee II, with both version the problem is there. When I downgraded to version 264a0700, just like @funkstille, the problem was resolved and now everything seems to be running as expected.
If there is anything I can do to help resolving the problem, which seems to be in combination with the ConBee II most recent firmware versions, please let me know.
@MGdRomph Did the Hue bulbs become unresponsive after pairing or did they already run for a while? And do you have any IKEA bulbs in your network?
Hello,
I made you by my experience having a conbee II and also problems with my HUE bulbs.
I tested different firmware of the conbee here is the list of firmware that worked
OK -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x264a0700.bin.GCF 27-May-2019 10:03
Not tested -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26570700.bin.GCF 27-Apr-2020 09:59
OK -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26580700.bin.GCF 10-May-2020 13:16
KO -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26650700.bin.GCF 13-Sep-2020 15:46
KO -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26660700.bin.GCF 07-Oct-2020 10:19
KO -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26670700.bin.GCF 18-Nov-2020 12:51
KO -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26680700.bin.GCF 30-Nov-2020 18:03
KO -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26700700.bin.GCF 11-Aug-2021 07:39
KO -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26720700.bin.GCF 19-Aug-2021 22:20
I remain available to advance the subject
sorry for my English
@MGdRomph Did the Hue bulbs become unresponsive after pairing or did they already run for a while? And do you have any IKEA bulbs in your network?
At that point I was migrating some HUE bulbs from the HUE bridge to ConBee II/Zigbee2Mqtt, after pairing they worked a couple of commands and then became unresponsive. I have no IKEA bulbs in my network but the two bulbs that became unresponsive do have the new firmware version 67.91.1, all the other bulbs (that work fine) have version 67.88.1.
what's the version of your conbee || ?
what's the version of your conbee || ?
At this moment I am using 264a0700, as this was the version metioned by @funkstille that worked for him. And thanks for testings all versions of the firmware, I will give version 26580700 and 26650700 a try as well just to verify if indeed the problem arrises between those two versions.
With the ConBee II firmware version 26650700 both HUE bulbs with firmware version 67.91.1 stopped responding after a few minutes (one almost directly, the other one stayed working for about a minute or two).
After that I downgraded to ConBee II firmware version 26580700. Bulbs still didn't respond but after a power cycle both bulbs did became responsive again (I did turn on "permit join" in Zigbee2Mqtt as well) and are working still working fine.
Just like @Anonymenet77 already wrote, with firmware version 26580700 all seems to be working fine from version 26650700 and up my HUE bulbs with firmware version 67.91.1 become unresponsive after some time.
With the ConBee II firmware version 26650700 both HUE bulbs with firmware version 67.91.1 stopped responding after a few minutes (one almost directly, the other one stayed working for about a minute or two).
After that I downgraded to ConBee II firmware version 26580700. Bulbs still didn't respond but after a power cycle both bulbs did became responsive again (I did turn on "permit join" in Zigbee2Mqtt as well) and are working still working fine.
Just like @Anonymenet77 already wrote, with firmware version 26580700 all seems to be working fine from version 26650700 and up my HUE bulbs with firmware version 67.91.1 become unresponsive after some time.
For my part my concern is resolved since I was in version of CONZ_ConBeeII_0x26580700.bin.GCF 10-Mai-2020 13:16 👍
do you still have the problem even after changing firmware?
With the ConBee II firmware version 26650700 both HUE bulbs with firmware version 67.91.1 stopped responding after a few minutes (one almost directly, the other one stayed working for about a minute or two). After that I downgraded to ConBee II firmware version 26580700. Bulbs still didn't respond but after a power cycle both bulbs did became responsive again (I did turn on "permit join" in Zigbee2Mqtt as well) and are working still working fine. Just like @Anonymenet77 already wrote, with firmware version 26580700 all seems to be working fine from version 26650700 and up my HUE bulbs with firmware version 67.91.1 become unresponsive after some time.
For my part my concern is resolved since I was in version of CONZ_ConBeeII_0x26580700.bin.GCF 10-Mai-2020 13:16 👍
do you still have the problem even after changing firmware?
I am using 26580700 now as well, that works fine.
Just upgraded four of my first generation HUE lighs (3 bulbs, 1 LED strip) to firmware version 67.91.1. Ever since, these four lights have become really sluggish to react at times. When turning on or off the lights, at times they don't seem to react at all. After waiting a bit, they eventually change state. Since this happens only with these first gen lights since the OTA update, my suspicion is on the firmware. I got quite a few other HUE lights running, also ones that are right next to the first gen lights, and those work just fine.
BTW: I don't have a ConbeeII stick active. My current setup uses the Slaesh's CC2652RB stick.
I have 3 philips lights: bakgården1, 2 and 3, and a zigbee group "bakgården". They are quite close to each other. Lights 1 and 3 are controllable like they should be. Light 2, located in the middle, is not. When I switch it on/off there's no reaction except for the message:
Publish 'set' 'state' to 'Bakgården2' failed: 'Error: Command 0x0017880102b354a7/11 genOnOff.on({}, {"sendWhenActive":false,"timeout":10000,"disableResponse":false,"disableRecovery":false,"disableDefaultResponse":false,"direction":0,"srcEndpoint":null,"reservedBits":0,"manufacturerCode":null,"transactionSequenceNumber":null,"writeUndiv":false}) failed (no response received)'
BUT: When I switch on/off/dim using the group, all 3 lights behave just fine! And no error messages. This seems, to me, very strange. Bug in zigbee2mqtt? or in ConBee II?
I have the same problem. I have 50 devices with none with less that 240 LQI. All routers are HUE. I use deconz conbee II with firmware 26720700. Zigbee2MQTT 1.22.2 commit 1a0a9a6e
I have 3 philips lights: bakgården1, 2 and 3, and a zigbee group "bakgården". They are quite close to each other. Lights 1 and 3 are controllable like they should be. Light 2, located in the middle, is not. When I switch it on/off there's no reaction except for the message:
Publish 'set' 'state' to 'Bakgården2' failed: 'Error: Command 0x0017880102b354a7/11 genOnOff.on({}, {"sendWhenActive":false,"timeout":10000,"disableResponse":false,"disableRecovery":false,"disableDefaultResponse":false,"direction":0,"srcEndpoint":null,"reservedBits":0,"manufacturerCode":null,"transactionSequenceNumber":null,"writeUndiv":false}) failed (no response received)'
BUT: When I switch on/off/dim using the group, all 3 lights behave just fine! And no error messages. This seems, to me, very strange. Bug in zigbee2mqtt? or in ConBee II?I have the same problem. I have 50 devices with none with less that 240 LQI. All routers are HUE. I use deconz conbee II with firmware 26720700. Zigbee2MQTT 1.22.2 commit 1a0a9a6
Upgraded to Z2M 1.23.0 and tried FW 26580700 and 26680700. Does not make any diff.
Did you powercycle the bulbs and restart z2mqtt?
did you check if flashing the the stick turned out ok. Maybe downgrade did not work…?
sudo GCFFlasher_internal -t 60 -d /dev/ttyACM0 -f deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x264a0700.bin.GCF
GCFFlasher V3_17 (c) dresden elektronik ingenieurtechnik gmbh
Reboot device /dev/serial/by-id/usb-dresden_elektronik_ingenieurtechnik_GmbH_ConBee_II_DE2214230-if00 (ConBee II)
deCONZ firmware version 26680700
Yeah i did a complete new installation of z2m and powercycled all bulbs. I did check the firmware after all flashes and also unplugged the device before and after the flash.
Hello,
try the following firmwares for me it solved the problem. I haven't had any issues since.
OK -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x264a0700.bin.GCF 27-May-2019 10:03 Not tested -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26570700.bin.GCF 27-Apr-2020 09:59 OK -> deCONZ_ConBeeII_0x26580700.bin.GCF 10-May-2020 13:16
Already tried 0x26580700.bin.GCF, did not work. Also tried 0x264a0700.bin.GC now. Did not solve the issue.
This issue is stale because it has been open 30 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 7 days
Same problem here with conbeeII as Home Assistant Addon in Firmware 26660700 and only two philips hue light bulbs. Usb extension in use. The problem was always there
Running my environment on a Homeassistant Supervised installation based on Linux. Can I take my Conbee stick out of this system and flash it on a different machine using the update instructions? Will I lose my configuration on the stick? Some lights are also unstable in my situation. Running combination of Ikea and Hue bulbs
@hscholing did it the same way as you are planing to do it and it worked for me
Unsure if this is the same issue but I am also having devices go offline in zigbee2mqtt. I have definitely seen Hue and Gledopto devices go offline but not sure about the others.
Interestingly, the "offline" devices are still controllable through groups. I also find that restarting zigbee2mqtt and waiting ~15 minutes brings them all back online again.
Zigbee2MQTT version: 1.25.0
Coordinator type: ConBee2/RaspBee2
Coordinator revision: 0x26580700
Total 63
By device type
Router: 42
End devices: 21
By power source
Mains (single phase): 42
Battery: 21
By vendor
Signify Netherlands B.V.: 19
IKEA of Sweden: 19
Philips: 9
LUMI: 6
LDS: 5
GLEDOPTO: 4
KE: 1
Sorry just found #11650 which looks more relevant to my issue above. Will check that and post there if still having issues.
This issue is stale because it has been open 30 days with no activity. Remove stale label or comment or this will be closed in 7 days
Just upgraded four of my first generation HUE lighs (3 bulbs, 1 LED strip) to firmware version 67.91.1. Ever since, these four lights have become really sluggish to react at times. When turning on or off the lights, at times they don't seem to react at all. After waiting a bit, they eventually change state. Since this happens only with these first gen lights since the OTA update, my suspicion is on the firmware. I got quite a few other HUE lights running, also ones that are right next to the first gen lights, and those work just fine.
BTW: I don't have a ConbeeII stick active. My current setup uses the Slaesh's CC2652RB stick.
I have the same issue since updating my Hue Iris 7199960PH to FW 67.91.1. The lights are available and responsive for some seconds, then I get
Zigbee2MQTT:error 2022-06-29 00:43:54: Publish 'set' 'state' to 'Hue IRIS WoZi Ecke Sofa' failed: 'Error: Command 0x0017880101226bf0/11 genOnOff.on({}, {"sendWhen":"immediate","timeout":10000,"disableResponse":false,"disableRecovery":false,"disableDefaultResponse":false,"direction":0,"srcEndpoint":null,"reservedBits":0,"manufacturerCode":null,"transactionSequenceNumber":null,"writeUndiv":false}) failed (Timeout - 64128 - 11 - 22 - 6 - 11 after 10000ms)' Zigbee2MQTT:info 2022-06-29 00:43:54: MQTT publish: topic 'zigbee2mqtt/bridge/log', payload '{"message":"Publish 'set' 'state' to 'Hue IRIS WoZi Ecke Sofa' failed: 'Error: Command 0x0017880101226bf0/11 genOnOff.on({}, {\"sendWhen\":\"immediate\",\"timeout\":10000,\"disableResponse\":false,\"disableRecovery\":false,\"disableDefaultResponse\":false,\"direction\":0,\"srcEndpoint\":null,\"reservedBits\":0,\"manufacturerCode\":null,\"transactionSequenceNumber\":null,\"writeUndiv\":false}) failed (Timeout - 64128 - 11 - 22 - 6 - 11 after 10000ms)'","meta":{"friendly_name":"Hue IRIS WoZi Ecke Sofa"},"type":"zigbee_publish_error"}'
So I'm pretty sure it is a FW issue of the hue bulbs. Is there any chance to downgrade the FW of the bulbs?
My configuration uses an Electrolama zig-a-zig-ah! (zzh!) CC2652R adapter.
After some more tests, I tend to say, that with the update the Hue lights lost massively in signal strenght. Everything seems to be ok as log as the devices are very close to the coordinator. But as soon as they move away, link quality is massively reduced. Even close to the coordinator the values are lower than before the update at very distant positions in the network. I even have the assumption that somehow the devices lost their router capability...
Made a networkmap and yes, the Hue Iris are completely unconnected within each other and also with the coordinator. Signal quality is always 0. I really wonder, what they did at Philips with this FW update...
can not confirm. At least in my case with the downgraded ConBeeII Stick they are working as coordinator / sibling.
@funkstille: Did you make a network map to check the link quality within your Hue equipment before downgrading? Was it different from after the downgrade? I still wonder why the IRIS do not connect to each other although they are right beside each other. There is no such problem with other devices like e.g. OSRAM plug which is at the same spot than one of my IRIS...
The release notes for the release 67.91.1 says something about "security issues". I wonder if it has to do something with that. That could at least explain why it has something to do with the Stick and its FW, but I'm a complete moron when it comes to Zigbee itself...
Maybe I should completely setup the network from scratch...
No I did not check before and after. It was a kind of trial and error process. At the point everything was working again, I stopped and left it that way.
But during that time I also tried a reset and rebuild from scratch with no luck either. The only thing that worked for me was downgrading the conbeeII stick.
Many of my lights (Ikea and Philips) go unavailable from time to time (several times pr. week), and can't be contolled. After a while, sometimes, they come back online again. Sometimes a refresh in the z2m device panel brings the light back to life. But usually that doesn't help. Often I have to delete / add it. It seems like the lights farthest away from the controller suffer the most. All lights are quite evenly distributed in and around the house. The farthest distance from the ConBee is 20 meters. They are uncontrollable both from HA and from the Zigbee2mqtt UI. The same problem occurs with my Ikea Fyrtur blinds from time to time. Typical error message in the zigbee2mqtt log: "Publish 'set' 'state' to 'Utebod Lys2' failed: 'Error: Command 0x5c0272fffe840e54/1 genOnOff.off({}, {"sendWhenActive":false,"timeout":10000,"disableResponse":false,"disableRecovery":false,"disableDefaultResponse":false,"direction":0,"srcEndpoint":null,"reservedBits":0,"manufacturerCode":null,"transactionSequenceNumber":null,"writeUndiv":false}) failed (no response received)'" I have 55 mains powered devices (Ikea and Philips lights, wall plugs). 48 battery powered devices (Sensors, fyrtur blinds, switches).
What could be the reason for this behaviour, and what can I do to make it stable?
My config file:
What happened
Lights stop responding to Zigbee2Mqtt.
What did you expect to happen
Normal lights on/off for all lights.
How to reproduce it (minimal and precise)
This happens spontaneoulsy, it seems, with no prior action
Debug info
Zigbee2MQTT version: 1.22.0-2, Zigbee channel 25. Far away from any local WiFi channels (1, 6 and 8). Adapter hardware: Conbee II Adapter firmware version: 26720700, updated 7.nov. HA Core 2021.11.1, Supervisor 2021.10.8