KomodoPlatform / Agama

Discontinued software - DONT USE - only for educational purpose
https://komodoplatform.com
MIT License
32 stars 46 forks source link

Suggestion to save techsupport and users a ton of headaches. - Text Visibility #21

Closed polycryptoblog closed 5 years ago

polycryptoblog commented 6 years ago

In Agama's passphrase input screen there is an option by clicking on the eye to render the text you are inputting as visible. Currently the default mode is obscured text. (****) The default mode should be visible text. Numerous complaints from users losing or mistyping or incorrectly saving their passphrase. This simple change can mitigate this drastically.

pbca26 commented 6 years ago

this poses a security threat if you're in a public place there's a reason why pw fields are usually masked on any websites

polycryptoblog commented 6 years ago

How many people are typing a 24 word passphrase in a public place? Pretty hard to shoulder surf that as well. Not to mention one could just click the eye again to mask it if they are concerned about it. These new users are not used to typing in long phrases, also i have noticed that if you wait a little after typing a space it will backspace. I believe part of the issue is when they are typing the passphrase in, they trip this mechanism and when they think they are typing "apple duck birch keys" they are actually typing "appleduck birch keys"

polycryptoblog commented 6 years ago

I've dealt with a dozen or so people in the past few days that had issue with this, yes it is user stupidity, but that's why we have to make it stupid proof

jdmarlow86 commented 5 years ago

Is this ok to close?

sawlysawly commented 5 years ago

Yes I think this issues should to be closed with wontfix labels.

There is good security reasons to use hidden text by the default.