Converting a mesh file - Githubissues

zanderder commented 1 year ago

Dear All,

I am using Meshmagick to convert a mesh file (preferably from Salome) into .dat for use with Nemoh and am following the user's guide, but I found the problems below.

This line worked fine. meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -o SEAREV.mar

And I got the converted file C:\Windows\System32\meshmagick>meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -o SEAREV.mar

============================================= meshmagick - version 3.4 Copyright 2014-2023, Ecole Centrale de Nantes / D-ICE Engineering =============================================_ SEAREV.vtp successfully loaded Writing SEAREV.mar WARNING: if you described only one part of the mesh using symmetry for Nemoh, you may manually modify the file header accordingly -> Done.

============================================================= Meshmagick - version 3.4 Copyright 2014-2023, Ecole Centrale de Nantes / D-ICE Engineering Maintainer : Francois Rongere Francois.Rongere@dice-engineering.com Good Bye! =============================================================

However, when I ran the following line, error popped up. I completely have no idea about what is going wrong, and I have also tried to convert other types of mesh, but ended in failure with the same error.

meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -ifmt paraview SEAREV.vtp -ofmt nemoh SEAREV.dat

C:\Windows\System32\meshmagick>meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -ifmt paraview SEAREV.vtp -ofmt nemoh SEAREV.dat usage: meshmagick [-h] [-o OUTFILENAME] [-ifmt INPUT_FORMAT] [-ofmt OUTPUT_FORMAT] [-q] [-i] [--quality] [-t Tx Ty Tz] [-tx Tx] [-ty Ty] [-tz Tz] [-r Rx Ry Rz] [-rx Rx] [-ry Ry] [-rz Rz] [-s S] [-sx Sx] [-sy Sy] [-sz Sz] [-hn] [-fn] [-hm] [-p Arg [Arg ...]] [-c [Arg ...]] [-cc CONCATENATE_FILE] [-md [Tol]] [-tq] [-sym [Arg ...]] [--mirror Arg [Arg ...]] [-pi] [-si] [--rho-medium RHO_MEDIUM] [--list-medium] [--thickness THICKNESS] [-pn Project Name] [-hs] [-mdisp Disp] [-cog Xg Yg Zg] [-zg Zcog] [-lpp Lpp] [-ap] [-wd Rho] [-g G] [--hs-report filename] [-lid [Arg ...]] [-mesh_size MESH_SIZE] [-sh] [-v] infilename meshmagick: error: unrecognized arguments: SEAREV.vtp SEAREV.dat

To convert .dat mesh file from salome:

meshmagick Mesh.dat -ifmt salome Mesh.dat -ofmt nemoh Mesh_new.dat

C:\Windows\System32\meshmagick>meshmagick Mesh.dat -ifmt salome Mesh.dat -ofmt nemoh Mesh_new.dat usage: meshmagick [-h] [-o OUTFILENAME] [-ifmt INPUT_FORMAT] [-ofmt OUTPUT_FORMAT] [-q] [-i] [--quality] [-t Tx Ty Tz] [-tx Tx] [-ty Ty] [-tz Tz] [-r Rx Ry Rz] [-rx Rx] [-ry Ry] [-rz Rz] [-s S] [-sx Sx] [-sy Sy] [-sz Sz] [-hn] [-fn] [-hm] [-p Arg [Arg ...]] [-c [Arg ...]] [-cc CONCATENATE_FILE] [-md [Tol]] [-tq] [-sym [Arg ...]] [--mirror Arg [Arg ...]] [-pi] [-si] [--rho-medium RHO_MEDIUM] [--list-medium] [--thickness THICKNESS] [-pn Project Name] [-hs] [-mdisp Disp] [-cog Xg Yg Zg] [-zg Zcog] [-lpp Lpp] [-ap] [-wd Rho] [-g G] [--hs-report filename] [-lid [Arg ...]] [-mesh_size MESH_SIZE] [-sh] [-v] infilename meshmagick: error: unrecognized arguments: Mesh.dat Mesh_new.dat

When I ran the first line through Git Bash, there was also an error, though both meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -i and meshmagick SEAREV.vtp --quality worked fine. $ meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -o SEAREV.mar

============================================= meshmagick - version 3.4 Copyright 2014-2023, Ecole Centrale de Nantes / D-ICE Engineering ============================================= SEAREV.vtp successfully loaded Writing SEAREV.mar Traceback (most recent call last): File "C:\Users\xxxxxx\AppData\Local\Programs\Python\Python311\Scripts\meshmagick-script.py", line 33, in sys.exit(load_entry_point('meshmagick', 'console_scripts', 'meshmagick')()) ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ File "c:\windows\system32\meshmagick\meshmagick_cli.py", line 1021, in main mmio.write_mesh(args.outfilename, mesh.vertices, mesh.faces, format) File "c:\windows\system32\meshmagick\meshmagick\mmio.py", line 1124, in write_mesh writer(filename, vertices, faces) File "c:\windows\system32\meshmagick\meshmagick\mmio.py", line 1633, in write_MAR ofile = open(filename, 'w') ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ PermissionError: [Errno 13] Permission denied: 'SEAREV.mar'

Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.

Regards, Zander

mancellin commented 1 year ago

meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -ifmt paraview SEAREV.vtp -ofmt nemoh SEAREV.dat

In your command, the input file SEAREV.vtp is given twice and the output file is not labelled with -o. What about something like the following (untested)?

meshmagick -ifmt paraview -ofmt nemoh -o SEAREV.mar SEAREV.vtp

All arguments are preceded with a - label except for the input file.

Not sure what is going on with the GitBash issue.

zanderder commented 1 year ago

Thank you Mancellin.

It is an example command given in the user's guide. I tested the command you suggested, and it did not work out (OSError: Extension ".paraview" is not known), unfortunately.

I am really confused, other example commands work well, but this one does not.

mancellin commented 1 year ago

Indeed. According to the reference list of supported formats, the keyword paraview is not associated with any kind of file. You should either use the keyword vtp instead or trust meshmagick to recognize the .vtp file extension.

This example from the documentation looks wrong to me, but maybe I'm missing something.

zanderder commented 1 year ago

Indeed. According to the reference list of supported formats, the keyword paraview is not associated with any kind of file. You should either use the keyword vtp instead or trust meshmagick to recognize the .vtp file extension.

This example from the documentation looks wrong to me, but maybe I'm missing something.

You are right. It did the conversion successfully when I removed the keyword paraview. I used the following command:

meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -ifmt vtp -ofmt nemoh -o SEAREV.dat

I kept nemoh because I would like to have the .dat file of Nemoh format, and it worked (though I am not sure whether the conversion is correct). The strange thing is that it does not work if I replace nemoh with dat (which is the extension of the output file), i.e., meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -ifmt vtp -ofmt dat -o SEAREV.dat.

mancellin commented 1 year ago

I kept nemoh because I would like to have the .dat file of Nemoh format, and it worked (though I am not sure whether the conversion is correct). The strange thing is that it does not work if I replace nemoh with dat (which is the extension of the output file), i.e., meshmagick SEAREV.vtp -ifmt vtp -ofmt dat -o SEAREV.dat.

According to the documentation page I linked above, the keyword for Nemoh format is either nemoh or mar, but not dat (although the file has commonly the extension .dat).