v1.3.0 - unable to get iscsi tgt implementation working

[acidrop]

I'm testing linstor-gateway v1.3.0 and the new feature for iscsi tgt implementation, however I'm unable to get it working. Another user seem to have reported a similar issue in drbd-user mailing list...

https://lists.linbit.com/pipermail/drbd-user/2023-October/026493.html

Please also see attached log file.

linstor-gateway -v
linstor-gateway version 1.3.0

dpkg -l|grep tgt
ii  tgt                                  1:1.0.85-1                          amd64        Linux SCSI target user-space daemon and tools

linstor-gateway iscsi create iqn.2019-08.com.linbit:iscsi-lun1 10.10.3.10/24 10G --resource-group iscsi-group --implementation tgt

linstor-gateway iscsi list
+-----------------------------------+---------------+----------------+-----+---------------+
|                IQN                |  Service IP   | Service state  | LUN | LINSTOR state |
+-----------------------------------+---------------+----------------+-----+---------------+
| iqn.2019-08.com.linbit:iscsi-lun1 | 10.10.3.10/24 | Started (pve1) |   1 | OK            |
+-----------------------------------+---------------+----------------+-----+---------------+

Resource is moving between the nodes, but never starts properly. HA VIP also does not respond to ping requests.

root@pve1:~# drbdadm status
iscsi-lun1 role:Secondary
  volume:0 disk:Diskless
  volume:1 disk:Diskless
  pve2 role:Primary
    volume:0 peer-disk:UpToDate
    volume:1 peer-disk:UpToDate
  pve3 role:Secondary
    volume:0 peer-disk:UpToDate
    volume:1 peer-disk:UpToDate

root@pve1:~# drbdadm status
iscsi-lun1 role:Secondary
  volume:0 disk:Diskless
  volume:1 disk:Diskless
  pve2 role:Secondary
    volume:0 peer-disk:UpToDate
    volume:1 peer-disk:UpToDate
  pve3 role:Secondary
    volume:0 peer-disk:UpToDate
    volume:1 peer-disk:UpToDate

lgtgterr.log

[chrboe]

Thank you for the report. To be honest, tgt was not really a big consideration when implementing this feature. The main intent was to allow usage with scst.

Of course, it should also work just as well with tgt. I'll investigate.

[acidrop]

Tested it with scst on Ubuntu 22.04 this time, and there seem to be issues with that too. I see the following line in the logs...

ocf-rs-wrapper[5165]: ocf-exit-reason:Unsupported iSCSI target implementation "scst"

 modinfo scst|head
filename:       /lib/modules/5.19.0-50-generic/updates/dkms/scst.ko
version:        3.7.0
description:    SCSI target core
license:        GPL
author:         Vladislav Bolkhovitin
srcversion:     77B4564098FA1279F50855C
depends:        dlm
retpoline:      Y
name:           scst
vermagic:       5.19.0-50-generic SMP preempt mod_unload modversions

 dpkg -l|grep resource-agents
ii  resource-agents                      1:4.7.0-1ubuntu7.2                      all          Transitional package for the resource-agents
ii  resource-agents-base                 1:4.7.0-1ubuntu7.2                      all          Cluster Resource Agents curated by Ubuntu
ii  resource-agents-common               1:4.7.0-1ubuntu7.2                      amd64        Common files used by the Cluster Resource Agents
ii  resource-agents-extra                1:4.7.0-1ubuntu7.2                      amd64        Cluster Resource Agents

Attaching logs...

ubuntu_lgw_scst.log

[chrboe]

That I can probably explain.

scst support was only very recently added to resource-agents, with this pull request to be precise: https://github.com/ClusterLabs/resource-agents/pull/1890

That was only released in version 4.13.0 of resource-agents, so you should make sure you are running that version.

[acidrop]

That I can probably explain.

scst support was only very recently added to resource-agents, with this pull request to be precise: ClusterLabs/resource-agents#1890

That was only released in version 4.13.0 of resource-agents, so you should make sure you are running that version.

Thanks for this. Sorry for drifting to a different subject from the original, but I installed v4.13.0 of resource-agents and this time it's showing a different error.. Do you think this that this is some kind of misconfiguration on my end ? scst kernel module seems to be loaded. LIO target (i.e without using --implementation argument) is working fine by the way, even with v4.13.0.

lsmod|grep scst
scst                 3579904  0
dlm                   237568  1 scst

Nov 07 14:02:43 pve1 ocf-rs-wrapper[47220]: Nov 07 14:02:43 ERROR:  Collecting current configuration: done. -> Making requested changes. -> Creating target 'iqn.2019-08.com.linbit:iscsi-lu
n2' for driver 'iscsi': done. -> Done. WARNING: Received the following error: No such driver exists. All done.
Nov 07 14:02:43 pve1 ocf-rs-wrapper[47220]: Nov 07 14:02:43 ERROR:  Collecting current configuration: done. -> Making requested changes. WARNING: Received the following error: targetAttrib
utes(): Driver 'iscsi' is not available -> Done. All done.
Nov 07 14:02:43 pve1 ocf-rs-wrapper[47220]: Nov 07 14:02:43 ERROR:  Collecting current configuration: done. -> Making requested changes. -> Adding new group 'allowed' to driver/target 'isc
si/iqn.2019-08.com.linbit:iscsi-lun2': done. FATAL: Received the following error: No such driver exists.
Nov 07 14:02:43 pve1 ocf-rs-wrapper[47220]: Nov 07 14:02:43 INFO:  Collecting current configuration: done. -> Making requested changes. WARNING: Received the following error: targetAttribu
tes(): Driver 'iscsi' is not available -> Done. All done.
Nov 07 14:02:43 pve1 ocf-rs-wrapper[47220]: /usr/lib/ocf/resource.d/heartbeat/iSCSITarget: line 430: /sys/kernel/scst_tgt/targets/iscsi/enabled: No such file or directory
Nov 07 14:02:43 pve1 ocf-rs-wrapper[47218]: ERROR [ocf_rs_wrapper] iSCSITarget:target_iscsi\x2dlun2,s-a-m,start: FAILED with exit code 7

[chrboe]

You need to modprobe scst, iscsi-scst, and scst_vdisk. Also, you need to start the iscsi-scstd userspace daemon.

Should probably document that somewhere... :upside_down_face: