search

LMMS / lmms

Cross-platform music production software
https://lmms.io
GNU General Public License v2.0
8.13k stars 1.01k forks source link

VyNil: make effect stop makin noise when not playing in some editor #6120

Open JGHFunRun opened 3 years ago

JGHFunRun commented 3 years ago

Enhancement Summary

When you're not playing in the BnB, song editor or piano roll VyNil shouldn't make noise

Justification

Having noise be in the background when nothing is playing is really annoying, and although I can mute it having to mute/unmute everytime I wanna play something is annoying.

Spekular commented 3 years ago

Duplicate of #4700, which was closed as a duplicate of #3170. Leaving this open because I think the issues might be separate.

zonkmachine commented 5 months ago

Duplicate of #4700, which was closed as a duplicate of #3170. Leaving this open because I think the issues might be separate.

Actually, yes this is a duplicate of #4700 but #3170 is a separate issue.

There are quite a few plugins that are active and make some sound even though the project has stopped. Our own Flanger has a noise source and if you turn it up, once a project has started playing, the noise will continue even after stopping the pattern/song playback. Since I'm more used to live music in rehearsal rooms with a random flanger plugged into an amp, I rather expect this to happen but I do understand that this isn't ideal for all. I don't know what's the most common/expected way other DAW's do this.

zonkmachine commented 5 months ago

Here is the issue recreated with lmms flanger. Once you hit play, there is no stopping. noise.mmp.txt