Labdoo 2.0 Drupal 7 Module Analysis

greggmarshall commented 2 years ago

I took the .make file for Labdoo 2.0, which is Drupal 7, and reviewed each module and theme. Here are the results of that review:

Themes

bootstrap - bootstrap is D9 compatible, if you want to continue using Bootstrap 3, if you want Bootstrap 4 or 5, the barrio theme seems to be popular
labdoo custom theme will need to be completely rebuilt since the template engine from Drupal 7 isn't used any more, replaced by Twig
gin - recommended administration theme, extends claro, which will replace seven in D10

Modules that have a Drupal 9 compatible version

addtoany - D9 compatible
antibot - D9 compatible
calendar - D9 compatible in alpha release
captcha - D9 compatible
coder - D9 compatible, doesn't install as a module any more
colorbox - D9 compatible
computed_field - D9 compatible in alpha release
conditional_fields - D9 compatible in alpha release
context - D9 compatible
ctools - D9 compatible
delete_all - D9 compatible
devel - D9 compatible
diff - D9 compatible
disqus - D9 compatible, also has a new version in alpha release
drush_language - D9 compatible, need to check compatibility with Drush 11 and might be redundant, https://www.drupal.org/project/drush_language/issues/3180653
entityreference_filter - D9 compatible
eva - D9 compatible
extlink - D9 compatible
field_group - D9 compatible
flag - D9 compatible in beta release
flexslider - D9 compatible
google_analytics - D9 compatible
homebox - D9 compatible with warning about using in production
honeypot - D9 compatible
imce - D9 compatible, might look at using core's media library instead
lang_dropdown - D9 compatible
legal - D9 compatible
linkchecker - D9 compatible
mailsystem - D9 compatible
mass_contact - D9 compatible
memcache - D9 compatible
mimemail - D9 compatible
node_export - D9 compatible
node_view_permissions - D9 compatible, why?
pathauto - D9 compatible
plupload - D9 compatible
publishcontent - D9 compatible, replace with content moderation?
r4032login - D9 compatible
recaptcha - D9 compatible
reroute_email - D9 compatible
role_delegation - D9 compatible
search_autocomplete - D9 compatible
sharethis - D9 compatible
simplenews - D9 compatible
smtp - D9 compatible
spambot - D9 compatible
subpathauto - D9 compatible
token - D9 compatible
user_restrictions - D9 compatible
video_filter - D9 compatible
view_unpublished - D9 compatible
views_autocomplete_filters - D9 compatible
views_slideshow - D9 compatible
views_tree - D9 compatible in alpha version

Note that modules will need to be manually configured and configuration exported. Do not attempt to use the existing Drupal 7 features, they will not work.

Modules that do not have a Drupal 9 version or have been incorporated into Drupal core

boost - replaced by D9 core caching
boxes - no D8/D9 version
countries - no D8/D9 version
date - Moved into D9 core, if you want more functionality look at smart_date
drupal_wall - no D8/D9 version
drupalchat - no D8/D9 version, switch to rocket_chat?
edit_profile - no D8/D9 version
email - Moved into D9 core
entity - Moved into D9 core, not sure why there's a D8/D9 version
entityreference - Moved into D9 core
entityreference_prepopulate - no D8/D9 version
features - D9 compatible, but highly recommended not to use, replaced by core configuration management
features_extra - no D8/D9 version, likely not needed
field_collection - no D8/D9 version, usually replaced by paragraphs
file_entity - D9 compatible but not recommended by maintainers, mostly moved into core, should probably use media instead
gmap - no D8/D9 version, geolocation is recommended
google_adwords - no D8/D9 version
google_recaptcha - no D8/D9 version, replace with recaptcha module
hide_submit - no D8/D9 version
hybridauth - no D8/D9 version
i18n - Moved into D9 core
i18nviews - Moved into D9 core
imagecache_actions - no D8/D9 version, replaced by image_effects
imagemagick - D9 compatible, also there's imagick that uses the PHP extensio
imce_mkdir - no D8/D9 version
imce_wysiwyg - no D8/D9 version
ip_geoloc - no D8/D9 version, might look at smart_ip for ip to location lookup
jquery_update - no D8/D9 version, moved into core
l10n_update - Moved into D9 core
libraries - Moved into D9 core, there still is a D9 version for some functionality (never needed it)
location - no D8/D9 version, replace with geolocation and address modules, see also https://www.drupal.org/project/location_migration for migration automation
logintoboggan - no D8/D9 version
menu_view_unpublished - no D8/D9 version look at view_unpublished
migrate - Moved into D9 core, https://www.drupal.org/docs/upgrading-drupal/how-to-prepare-your-drupal-7-or-8-site-for-drupal-9
migrate_d2d - Moved into D9 core
module_filter - Moved into D9 core, not sure what D9 version adds
node_gallery - no D8/D9 version right be replacable with a view
nodeaccess_userreference - no D8/D9 version
oauth2_loginprovider - no D8/D9 version
og - D9 compatible, although mostly replaced in D8/D9 by group module (fewer than 1,000 D8/D9 sites use og va 12,000 group)
og_extras - no D8/D9 version
registration - no D8/D9 version, might look at https://www.drupal.org/project/smart_date_starter_kit
rules - D9 compatible although not very well supported, might also look at eca module which is new
search_config - no D8/D9 version
services - D9 compatible, although REST is built into D9 core
simplify - Moved into D9 core
special_menu_items - Moved into D9 core
stringoverrides - no D8/D9 version
strongarm - no D8/D9 version, deprecated by core configuration management
termcase - no D8/D9 version
transliteration - no D8/D9 version, this may have been moved into core
uuid - Moved into D9 core
variable - no D8/D9 version
views - Moved into D9 core
views_dependent_filters - no D8/D9 version
views_distinct - no D8/D9 version, there is an option in views for this
wysiwyg using tinymce - Moved into D9 core although using CKEDITOR
xautoload - no D8/D9 version, probably not needed since D9 has PSR-4 autoloading

jrosgiralt commented 2 years ago

great, let's discuss this during our meeting tomorrow. Thank you!

greggmarshall commented 2 years ago

This comment might be relevant to the homebox module if you move forward with it

https://www.drupal.org/project/gin_dashboard/issues/3251194#comment-14403892

jrosgiralt commented 2 years ago

@greggmarshall , how worrysome is this kind of warning when requiring a module via composer?

Package doctrine/reflection is abandoned, you should avoid using it. Use roave/better-reflection instead.
Package webmozart/path-util is abandoned, you should avoid using it. Use symfony/filesystem instead.

greggmarshall commented 2 years ago

Reasonably common. I usually ignore them.

sent from my phone Gregg Marshall, CPMR, CPSC

On Fri, Apr 29, 2022, 5:24 PM Jordi @.***> wrote:

@greggmarshall https://github.com/greggmarshall , how worrysome is this kind of warning when requiring a module via composer?

Package doctrine/reflection is abandoned, you should avoid using it. Use roave/better-reflection instead. Package webmozart/path-util is abandoned, you should avoid using it. Use symfony/filesystem instead.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/Labdoo/Labdoo-3.0/issues/2#issuecomment-1113873846, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAGWP5FWSUZGBM43MNXQCWDVHR4TBANCNFSM5O2XOYLQ . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

jrosgiralt commented 1 year ago

Hi @greggmarshall ,

The module nodeaccess_userreference (https://www.drupal.org/project/nodeaccess_userreference) is not available in D8/D9 version. Any thoughts on how I can have this feature? The use case is as follows:

I’d like to replicate a feature from the current Labdoo 2.0, which consists in a field in the dootronic content type that’s called “Additional editors”. This field allows an editor of the dootronic to add additional users that are then given edit rights of such a dootronic.

Thanks.

greggmarshall commented 1 year ago

@jrosgiralt Take a look at https://www.drupal.org/project/access_by_ref. I haven't used it but it looks like it might be a solution.

Labdoo / Labdoo-3.0