search

LaserWeb / lw.comm-server

Unified communications server for LaserWeb4 (and other frontends)
GNU General Public License v3.0
38 stars 47 forks source link

FEATURE: API for saving/loading settings #62

Open quintesse opened 6 years ago

quintesse commented 6 years ago

This would be the server part of https://github.com/LaserWeb/LaserWeb4/issues/49

A way for the UI to store and retrieve settings from the server. This way the user could easily set up different clients because the settings would already be available on the server that it connects to.

PS: Personally I'd be more than happy if this was a just a single "save slot", I myself don't have any use for multiple sets of machine profiles and settings on a single server, but perhaps others do?

cprezzi commented 6 years ago

It would not be a problem to save/load a single JSON formated settings string through the websocket connection, but I know there are users with multiple different machines that would need different profiles. Therefore it schould be possible to save multiple profiles, get a list of the available profiles and read a specific one. Give me some time to think about it...

quintesse commented 6 years ago

@cprezzi understood, I had just wanted to keep it simpler, but for people with multiple machines connected to a single server a single profile would not work indeed. Thanks for the feedback!

Gleapsite commented 5 years ago

there are users with multiple different machines that would need different profiles.

Meaning, one instance of lw.comm-server that can communicate with multiple machines.

Wouldn't this feature be similar to how the material database is handled?

cprezzi commented 5 years ago

@Gleapsite If you connect multiple machines to the PC running lw.comm-server, then you can select in the frontend, which machine (port) to connect. For example: I run lw.comm-server on a Raspberry Pi 3B+ and have connected two machines to it via USB. I can then decide which machine I want to work with by loading the matching machine porfile and connect the right USB port.

By the way, it's also possible to connect to lw.comm-server with more than one client at the same time. For example the PC to create the gcode and run the job and a tablet to watch and pause/resume the job.

quintesse commented 5 years ago

By the way, it's also possible to connect to lw.comm-server with more than one client at the same time. For example the PC to create the gcode and run the job and a tablet to watch and pause/resume the job.

@cprezzi it is? Is that new-ish functionality perhaps? Because I remember trying this many months ago and was surprised that I basically had to do the entire setup for each client and that each of them would see a different "state", so to speak. (Except for the actual physical state of the machine like laser position IIRC)

DataWorm commented 5 years ago

Yeah same here! Would love such a feature, the lack of globally stored settings is the main show-stopper for me. Octoprint fits more to what I expect except that it is more focussed on 3d printing. The lasercutter features of LaserWeb integrated in Octoprint as plugins would be awesome but LaserWeb by itself would be good enough with central storage! =)

quintesse commented 5 years ago

@DataWorm indeed, I use OctoPrint for my 3d printer and I love that I can access it in the exact same way from different clients. Something like that for a laser cutter would be excellent.

cprezzi commented 5 years ago

The machine profiles are still stored on client side and need to be copied manually to additional clients. What I said is that the server can handle multiple socket connections at the same time.

cprezzi commented 5 years ago

@quintesse You can also install lw-comm-server on a Raspberry Pi and access it from different clients (Win, Mac or Linux) either from a LaserWeb executable or just by a web browser. Only the profile that is used for the integrated gcode generation is stored on the client (only needs to be set up once).

What we don't have is the job storage on server side, so you could not upload gcode-files and run them later from a different client. But you could upload gcode generated by LW4 to OctoPrint, so you could run it later. It should not matter for OctoPrint, if the gcode file is for a 3d printer or a laser.

quintesse commented 5 years ago

@cprezzi yes, but that setup is pretty complex. Each time I use a new client (or a client that has its cache cleared) I need to put it side-by-side with a working client and carefully copy all the settings. Even exporting/importing is not trivial when your new client is a tablet or something (export, mail, save, import).

And my LW is already running on a RPi, so it would be a bit weird to use that to generate gcode, download it and then upload it to OctoPrint to start cutting.

I know, it's just the way things are, but personally I just wish LW worked more like OctoPrint :-)

cprezzi commented 5 years ago

@quintesse Yes, I understand that for your scenario it would be much easyer if the server had the profiles. This is also the way we work with the lasersaur in our FabLab. People just open the server webpage with their devices, upload the files and then go to the PC aside the laser to run the job.

Maybe I will implement that server profile storage in the future, when I get some more time ;)

Gleapsite commented 5 years ago

Yes. In my ideal use case, I could connect to any given machine from an arbitrary client, and have that given machine's settings, job history, and materials database.

To me, thats machine-specific data, as opposed to client specific.

@cprezzi thank you for all the time you've put into this project already. I wish I could help, but I'm not very fluent in nodejs