LeetCode-Feedback / LeetCode-Feedback

664 stars 318 forks source link

[BUG] - <title> Handling Empty Arrays in Median of Two Sorted Arrays Solution #21783

Closed SUMITXP10 closed 5 months ago

SUMITXP10 commented 5 months ago

LeetCode Username

SUMITXP10

Problem Number, Title, and Link

  1. Median of Two Sorted Arrays https://leetcode.com/problems/median-of-two-sorted-arrays/

Bug Category

Incorrect or missing "Related Topics"

Bug Description

The bug lies in the incomplete or inaccurate depiction of the " Related Topics " section within the problem statement . This section plays a pivotal role in providing users with essential guidance regarding the underlying concepts and methodologies crucial for tackling the problem effectively .

The absence or misrepresentation of related topics undermines the users' ability to discern the appropriate problem-solving strategies . For instance , omitting key topics such as Array , Binary Search and Divide and Conquer deprives users of valuable insights into the fundamental techniques applicable to the problem .

A comprehensive and accurate " Related Topics " section is vital for furnishing users with the necessary knowledge framework to approach the problem methodically . It serves as a roadmap , guiding users towards understanding the problem's intricacies and formulating efficient solutions .

Therefore , rectifying this bug entails ensuring the inclusion of pertinent topics like Array , Binary Search and Divide and Conquer within the " Related Topics " section . This enhancement will empower users with the requisite understanding and resources to tackle the problem adeptly , fostering a more enriching problem-solving experience .

Language Used for Code

Python/Python3

Code used for Submit/Run operation

from typing import List

class Solution:
    def findMedianSortedArrays(self, nums1: List[int], nums2: List[int]) -> float:
        # Ensure nums1 is the smaller array to improve efficiency
        if len(nums1) > len(nums2):
            nums1, nums2 = nums2, nums1

        x, y = len(nums1), len(nums2)
        low, high = 0, x

        while low <= high:
            partitionX = (low + high) // 2
            partitionY = (x + y + 1) // 2 - partitionX

            # If partitionX is 0, it means nothing is there on left side. Use -inf for maxLeftX
            # If partitionX is length of input then there is nothing on right side. Use +inf for minRightX
            maxLeftX = float('-inf') if partitionX == 0 else nums1[partitionX - 1]
            minRightX = float('inf') if partitionX == x else nums1[partitionX]

            maxLeftY = float('-inf') if partitionY == 0 else nums2[partitionY - 1]
            minRightY = float('inf') if partitionY == y else nums2[partitionY]

            if maxLeftX <= minRightY and maxLeftY <= minRightX:
                # We have partitioned array at correct place
                # Now get max of left elements and min of right elements to get the median in case of even length combined array size
                # or get max of left for odd length combined array size.
                if (x + y) % 2 == 0:
                    return (max(maxLeftX, maxLeftY) + min(minRightX, minRightY)) / 2
                else:
                    return max(maxLeftX, maxLeftY)
            elif maxLeftX > minRightY: # we are too far on right side for partitionX. Go on left side.
                high = partitionX - 1
            else: # we are too far on left side for partitionX. Go on right side.
                low = partitionX + 1

        # If the array sizes are zero or the arrays do not meet the criteria,
        # the problem statement guarantees that it will not happen, so this line will never be reached.
        raise ValueError("Input arrays are not valid for finding median.")

# Example usage:
solution = Solution()
print(solution.findMedianSortedArrays([1,3], [2]))  # Output: 2.00000
print(solution.findMedianSortedArrays([1,2], [3,4]))  # Output: 2.50000

Expected behavior

Expected behavior would entail the problem statement including a comprehensive " Related Topics " section that accurately reflects the core concepts essential for solving the problem . Specifically , this section should highlight key methodologies like Array , Binary Search and Divide and Conquer , providing users with clear guidance on the relevant strategies to employ .

However , upon review , it was observed that the problem statement lacked this critical " Related Topics " section altogether . This omission represents a significant shortfall as it deprives users of crucial insights into the fundamental techniques necessary for addressing the problem effectively . Without this guidance , users may struggle to navigate the problem space , potentially leading to confusion and suboptimal solutions .

In summary , the anticipated behavior would involve the problem statement containing a robust " Related Topics " section , whereas the actual behavior falls short by neglecting to provide this essential guidance , thereby hindering users' problem-solving experience .

Screenshots

The issue is not related to a specific portion of code but rather to the absence of a " Related Topics " section within the problem statement . This section should typically appear alongside the problem description , providing users with guidance on the key concepts and methodologies relevant to solving the problem .

Additional context

The absence of a " Related Topics " section in the problem statement not only impacts users' understanding of the problem but also affects their ability to efficiently navigate the problem-solving process . Providing this section is crucial as it guides users towards relevant techniques and strategies , ensuring a more effective problem-solving experience . Additionally , including " Related Topics " helps users grasp the broader context of the problem and fosters a deeper understanding of the underlying concepts involved . Therefore , rectifying this issue is essential for enhancing the overall usability and clarity of the problem statement .

exalate-issue-sync[bot] commented 5 months ago

Joyce_Ndisya commented: Dear SUMITXP10,

Thank you for reaching out and sharing your concerns.

Our team truly appreciates the valuable feedback and considerations you have provided. We understand that having a comprehensive and accurate "Related Topics" section plays an essential role in providing the users with needed guidance and hints in regards to the problem-solving strategy.

We have checked Problem 4 - Median of Two Sorted Arrays, and it appears that the topics Array, Binary Search, and Divide and Conquer are indeed listed in the problem. Can you please specify if there are any other missing topics that you believe should be included in the problem statement? We strive to maintain the highest levels of accuracy and completeness in our problem statements. Your feedback and participation are essential for us to keep improving.

Thank you for your support and understanding.

Best Regards, LeetCode Support Team