LegionDark / Issues

[ARCHIVE] Issue tracking for the LegionDark private server.
10 stars 76 forks source link

AH prices needing adjustment. #615

Closed sirus628 closed 8 years ago

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

AH adjustment/Price Information


NPC buy/sell list WIP


New submissions
Template
Date/Time:
Character:
Item Name:
AHbot price:
NPC Buy/Sell price:
AH Category:
Max stack:
Exploitation(y/n/wtfbbq):

AH discrepancies open (strike-through completed)

- ~~Speed belt: 2.8mil  Sonic belt: 4mil Sonic belt +1: 4mil. 1.2mil profit for NQ. Very much exploited. Lvl 85 craft, HQ tier 1 available.~~

- ~~Imp. Mythryl coin: (stack)=150K (single)=15k    12+k profit selling single(1.18m total). Gold fine, Silver+copper less than 3k profit margin.~~

- ~~Dragon Heart: (stack)=290k (single)=5k     Stack too high? Maybe an adjustment to 10k single 120k stack.~~

- Fishes:~~
    - ~~God Dragons:  Npc for around 10k each~~
        - ~~Sekiryu 5g~~
        - ~~Soryu 6g~~
        - ~~Kokuryu 4g~~
        - ~~Hakuryu 1g~~
    - ~~meatball (single) 5m~~
    - ~~Tavnazian goby (single) 17.9m~~

- ~~Spells:~~
   - ~~Songs~~
     -~~Army's Paeon III (3744 gil from vendor 30k on ah)~~
R3P0FFXI commented 8 years ago

@sirus628 Can you also go through the NPC list and get me info on spells that are bought and sold NPC to AH for crazy prices aside from what we fixed this am

R3P0FFXI commented 8 years ago

These prices have been adjusted

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

OK I will update the list

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

bump, updated the list with some important finds.

arigiris commented 8 years ago

There is the one listed in the new user guide of buying the Foe Requiem III from NPC Hortense in bastok market for 4653 Gil and sells on AH for 30k each. I admit I used this because I thought it was OK since it was specifically mentioned in the guide.

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

Its fine im sure the GMs dont mind that some people sold a few scrolls for a bonus. Doing that a bit inst any where near the scale of some of the unreported exploits. The AH will be fixed after it comes back dont worry.

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

Yeah, I for one have no plans to punish anyone over smallish profits from some ill advised guide info when there's billion gil black market meatball racketeering cartels to break up. All that should be done away with when the bot is restored.

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

I'm still :laughing: laughing that I just said "billion gil black market meatball racketeering cartels"

StoneRhyno commented 8 years ago

The Scroll of Barblizzard sells for 3624 in Lower Jeuno and for 30k on AH. I too was using the idea from the new player guide, I just happened across this scroll while killing time for my Chocobo License.

Additionally the Scroll of Barblizzara sells for 3624 and goes for 20k on AH. The other Bar spells sell similarly in that they cost a couple thousand (or less) and sell for 10k or so.

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

Italian tarutaru meatball syndicates. Like the damn minikuza. It cracked me up too cause I sold like 20 stacks of meatballs and never checked the single price hahah. So I unknowingly funded them with extra meatballs.

As for the spells I think they will just have to be set to the NPC sell price. Don't worry tho the guide was assuming you could only get 9 scrolls max at a time. Not list 400 meatballs at 5m haha. Or gobys for 17m.

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

Some items will could get deliberately left higher than NPC price, but the potential margin for NPC to AH shuttling would get cut far enough to make it not worth wasting time doing. It'd be more like making trips to a repeatable quest NPC - nobody ever made billions with a B from that, and quests have the bonus of building fame levels. At the outset while we rebuild a lot of things are just going to be NPC priced for safety reasons. We don't trust retail values anymore.

Darth12189 commented 8 years ago

A single chocobo feather can be bought from NPC for 8 gil and the AH-Bot price is over 48mil

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

Guys, keep in mind that the price history will still reflect things we had already fixed.

Until I wipe the entire thing to a clean slate to go with our new version of the bots pricing scheme that is...

Arrytha commented 8 years ago

It's not an exploit item, but while leveling cooking awhile back I noticed that Imperial Tea Leaves were 200k/stack. Is that because of the rarity of those in finding them in Wajaom and Bhaflau and not available from vendors? Only other common location wiki's say to get them is from Assault which I don't think is coded. I'm assuming the price is probably correct on this one?

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

@Arrytha most prices were taken from ffxiah.com values. So it reflects that. We will have to adjust a lot of items to match our economy and server considering the inflated prices and rarity changes.

So they may stay 200k or not even be listed. I know windy tea leaves are usually a hot ticket to post on ah after buying from NPC because most people don't want to go to the shop. Hopefully we will see a lot more player driven sales because of longer restock/buy times on ahbot.

I would love alchemy and lots of crafts to be useful. As well as a high tier HQ not to be useless because 9 are always on ah for basically the same as nq.

Arrytha commented 8 years ago

Yeah I agree. The first of two crafts I leveled was cooking and solely out of nostalgia from years ago on retail and never quite capping it. I realized, however, there was little value in cooking at all presently because there is buffed server food from @shop 2. Maybe making the buffed food into cooking recipes would be a good idea ;) Either way I'm continuing to get KIs for cooking just for old times sake haha

R3P0FFXI commented 8 years ago

@sirus628 @Arrytha the items in question have been resolved in the new AH files

@Arrytha you can craft the buffed food and sell it anyone can, you just have to actually craft it.

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

The buffed food items are overkill often, I see people paying 60k for something they will use for 5 min or less on a fight that they could have handled with a cheap meat jerky. Personally, I leveled a thf to 83 without even touching the buffed food items, but was grateful that the bot was listing cheaper alternatives when I'd NM camp something closer to my level or do a BCNM fight. My only use of buffed food was when I tried to solo the mission 5-1 ArchLich. I got him low HP (I forget exactly, but under 10%) and then wiped.

Arrytha commented 8 years ago

With the AH changes I hope people buy less of the buffed food since money will be more valuable now.

On Sun, Feb 28, 2016 at 2:40 PM, TeoTwawki notifications@github.com wrote:

The buffed food items are overkill often, I see people paying 60k for something they will use for 5 min or less on a fight that they could have handled with a cheap meat jerky. Personally, I leveled a thf to 83 without even touching the buffed food items, but was grateful that the bot was listing cheaper alternatives when I'd NM camp something closer to my level or do a BCNM fight. My only use of buffed fodo was when I tried to solo the mission 5-1 ArchLich. I got him low HP (I forget exactly, but under 10%) and then wiped.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/LegionDark/Issues/issues/615#issuecomment-189931380.

Joe Driver Survey Party Chief Terra Engineering and Land Solutions, PC 540-337-4591 http://www.terraengineering.net/

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

Updated the list with more information/ In anticipation of new findings.

It is a great gil sponge for the server. Especially with people multiboxing and getting money on every char for every kill.

It is not as helpful when you reach 99+ but it is still the ease of obtaining and the quick coverall bonus is nice.

Exactly what you would want in a good non-retail experience. There is already a huge potential to make lots of money off of some of the food such as creampuffs. and will be even more when the cap is raised for others.

I think having a bazaar/trade area would be very nice. Could even do something awesome like make an @tele bazaar. There are tons of people looking to Bazaar items but just never around many people. Mostly people are spread among the 3 starter cities because of OP warp/hp point warp so there is no reason to be any where else.

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

@sirus628 anytime you have to use an (at) symbol on GitHub and you aren't trying to tag a person, place backticks around the text @likethis otherwise its what GitHub calls a mention, which will send a notification to a person with that username.

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

R3P0FFXI has already gotten most of the new AH bot item list done. I thought we'd tag team it but he's been cruising along without me, making it exploit free.

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

@TeoTwawki I forgot my backticks lol

Yea I this will mostly be done as a exploit issue, mostly just an update/error/suggestion thing for the new stuff. Like if there is an npc overlooked with conflicting prices.

R3P0FFXI commented 8 years ago

@TeoTwawki @sirus628 @Loki79 @atom0s what are your thoughts on removing buffed food completely to make cooking a more prominent option?

Arrytha commented 8 years ago

I would be all over that! Cooking in FFXI inspired a real life passion to cook, no joke. On Feb 29, 2016 9:48 AM, "R3P0FFXI" notifications@github.com wrote:

@TeoTwawki https://github.com/TeoTwawki @sirus628 https://github.com/sirus628 @Loki79 https://github.com/Loki79 @atom0s https://github.com/atom0s what are your thoughts on removing buffed food completely to make cooking a more prominent option?

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/LegionDark/Issues/issues/615#issuecomment-190241714.

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

Prob with trying to get players cooking is we could wind up with either no food on Ah or nobody cooking because the bot still supplies food. One possibility is keep the buffed food but axe it from the shop command and the bot supply, so to get the super-food someone would have to craft and players would set the price. But the price would largely be decided by the recipe materials, and might just obsolete non buffed food.

Really anything we do is going to be a guess at how the players would react to scarcity (they might simply react as if food X doesn't exist, use food Y instead). They mostly aren't responding to that survey (only 6 people) I set up while the bot was offline, and the bot will be back soon, so there is virtually no data to go on.

Arrytha commented 8 years ago

I would cook for sure. I've been working on guild items even though there was no real point. Lol Another problem I can forsee is a lot of good food is made using fish, which to my knowledge isn't working. On Feb 29, 2016 10:30 AM, "TeoTwawki" notifications@github.com wrote:

Prob with trying to get players cooking is we could wind up with either no food on Ah or nobody cooking because the bot still supplies food. One possibility is keep the buffed food but axe it from the shop command and the bot supply, so to get the super-food someone would have to craft and players would set the price. But the price would largely be decided by the recipe materials, and might just obsolete non buffed food.

Really anything we do is going to be a guess at how the players would react to scarcity (they might simply react as if food X doesn't exist, use food Y instead). They mostly aren't responding to that survey (only 6 people) I set up while the bot was offline, and the bot will be back soon, so there is virtually no data to go on.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/LegionDark/Issues/issues/615#issuecomment-190257671.

sirus628 commented 8 years ago

@R3P0FFXI Only stock non HQ tier items.

Since some crafts rely on their amount produced as HQ stock and have little to no "white box+1" tier
(╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻

All consumables NQ = 187%(high end, 133 would work fine also) retail increase. All consumables HQ(Craft onry no ahbot) = 267.40% increase

No +1 items/gear by ahbot 110 crafts will make tons more common, eg. lvl 93-98 crafts will be instantly 10% HQ rate.

Aside from custom items this would make things like

To look at this alongside the shop 2 buffed food, NQ 187% vs HQ modded

Basically stock NQ at low amounts/long times. Set a good price, HQ will be player to player super bonus. Outweigh any shop items.

For AHbot buyback, once every 72 hrs buy all at mrsp or some kind of long time, to clear/restock any items. So you could still simulate a 5000 player market.

That would meet half way with allowing a fast paced non-retail feel like the old AH bot. Leveling from 20-50, selling the gear you get off ahbot back for MRSP, which is a very very nice feature. considering most of it is nostalgia at that level and just a bonus to ease leveling.

An easy way of setting up prices is a GM char buying/selling/fixing items from in game. Would really only just need Money to fix most, aside from listing new items with an MRSP or something to that affect.


cough we will need fishing cough

TeoTwawki commented 8 years ago

┬─┬ ノ( ゜-゜ノ)

An easy way of setting up prices is a GM char buying/selling/fixing items from in game. Would really only just need Money to fix most, aside from listing new items with an MRSP or something to that affect.

At no point will a GM be spending time trying to price fix anything. Bot exists specifically to not have to do stuff like that and provide simulated buyers and sellers.

Aside from that you are thinking like r3 already has: longer timings to make room for players. Its already set for when bot revives, and we'll see how people react and adjust as needed.

cough we will need fishing cough

Borked in DSP :cry: No choice but to stock fish or make fish into drops/NPC shops.

atom0s commented 8 years ago

Dumps have been made of the exploited AH history and queries have been made to easily find those that exploited it and how much they have made via the exploits. Justice will be served. Mwuahaha...

R3P0FFXI commented 8 years ago

FIxed in update