search

LeosonH / MACS30200proj

MACS 30200 (Perspectives in Computational Research) work repository
0 stars 0 forks source link

Review - Kanyao #3

Open khan1792 opened 6 years ago

khan1792 commented 6 years ago

A fantastic project with plenty of computational methods!

The layout of the poster is super clear, organized and logistic. Following the sections, I easily knows your research questions, methods and results in detail.

I have two suggestions for the layout:

  1. You may enlarge some pictures and tables. On the other hand, the reference and acknowledge takes up a little bit too much space.

  2. The poster has a bit too much text. I think you may remove some trivial content such as the python packages you use.

For the content, I appreciate you use both text aesthetic and layout aesthetic. It is a creative way since most papers I read just measure layout aesthetic. However, I have a suggestion/question about the text aesthetic.

You use document similarity of each article with the corpus to measure text aesthetic. However, I don't think document similarity can represent text aesthetic since it heavily relies on the substantial content and topic of the article rather than the stylistic form. You can use it as one variable, but it seems not enough. Actually, there are many other methods to detect the writing style. For example, some methods related to word frequency can help us identify the wording style. You can do more in the text aesthetic part.

LeosonH commented 6 years ago

Thanks for the review! I appreciate the suggestion and I agree with you! More proxy methods could have been used to try and get at the stylistic analysis.