nus-se-bot
commented
3 years ago Team's Response
Shopping List is not a feature within itself, but an underlying system that helps the user to keep track of item that they need to buy. shoplist,shopreset,add,remove,and update are the actual features which affect the underlying system which is the shoplist.
Hence, it would not be accurate to put it under features as it is not a command the user can use like the other features.
I've also downgraded the severity to very low as it would not affect the user because of where the info is located.
Items for the Tester to Verify
:question: Issue response
Team chose [response.Rejected]
- [x] I disagree
Reason for disagreement: Thank you for the response!
I agree that shopping list is not a feature itself, and it is inaccurate to put shopping list as a separate section under features. However, as you mentioned, it is an underlying system which is integrated to the remove feature, as adding to shopping list could only happen after the remove feature is used. Therefore, I suggested to place the information regarding shopping list under the remove feature section instead of placing it at the very end.
Moreover, as a user and tester, I was affected because of where the shopping list information is located. When I called the command help, the developers decided to list 2 commands related to the shopping list, which are shoplist and shopreset. As a user, I would definitely be inclined to use these features to my benefit as well. However, without knowing how to add to the shopping list until the very last section of the User Guide would definitely affect my understanding of this underlying system.
:question: Issue severity
Team chose [severity.VeryLow]
Originally [severity.Low]
- [x] I disagree
Reason for disagreement: Thank you for the response!
I agree that shopping list is not a feature itself, and it is inaccurate to put shopping list as a separate section under features. However, as you mentioned, it is an underlying system which is integrated to the remove feature, as adding to shopping list could only happen after the remove feature is used. Therefore, I suggested to place the information regarding shopping list under the remove feature section instead of placing it at the very end.
Moreover, as a user and tester, I was affected because of where the shopping list information is located. When I called the command help, the developers decided to list 2 commands related to the shopping list, which are shoplist and shopreset. As a user, I would definitely be inclined to use these features to my benefit as well. However, without knowing how to add to the shopping list until the very last section of the User Guide would definitely affect my understanding of this underlying system.
Shopping list is a feature, but only stated as an extra note. Perhaps, having a separate seection or moving it under the remove section (as it is integrated) could help.